Live data from Hacker News

Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

blog.hackermonthly.com

41–50 of 83 posts

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#41

I've been a print subscriber since May 2011 and I just wanted to say that my monthly issue of Hacker Monthly has consistently been a wonderful experience. The articles, the art, everything was very enjoyable. Thanks so much for having offered this service!

Thank you so much. That meant a lot to me.

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#42
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eh, this person doesn't want to do it anymore. They refunded people's money for the undelivered product. That's a pretty good way to handle it. Better than slagging along putting out a shitty product just because you can't quit. Time and energy is a resource just as much as money is. If your hobby project is sapping you of more than you get out of it, there's no shame in doing something else.

That's not really the point. Give it up and give the project to someone else or sell it. Now it's in limbo... What if someone else wants to do it? Will Lee sue? Is he really interested in litigation now? Who knows? It's a shame to end it like this.

Sue based on what? Just don't literally copy the name and design, and there's nothing to sue for.

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#43
post #25

I wod love to hear from the OP if he had explores transitioning, aka selling, this to someone. I think there is a market for the attention of people with money to spend, even in print magazines (especially in niche print magazines). But maybe he explored it and didn't find any takers, or maybe he doesn't want to deal with the hassle of such a transition. Would be nice to know.

As other comments have pointed out, not having the subscribers list is my non-negotiable terms if someone wants to take over. In fact, after I refunded everyone, I'll reset my server and remove all my DB backups so I won't even have a copy of it.

I know it doesn't make business sense for someone to buy a business without any customers. That's why I never explore the option of selling it.

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#45
A real shame. Hacker Monthly was a great product for the HN community and I'm going to miss it arriving in the post every month.

With that said, I think there's still a healthy ecosystem of similar products. There was a post on the front page about a new newsletter that sent out one "classic" HN post a week, I think the article mentioned it was doing pretty well. Can't remember its name though haha.

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#46
post #7

Thank you Lim Cheng Soon for all the hard work. I ran the same website for well over a decade and I know how it feels when creativity drops away. Consider passing the mantle to someone else to keep the publication going (if there is any interest), I did this and I don't regret it. After an apprentice period that person could then run it by themselves. That way your baby would get another shot at life even if you your…

Thanks Jacques! I'm thinking of "open sourcing" Hacker Monthly. The process of making it, the InDesign template I use (and optimized throughout the years), the resources etc. That way, anyone can start their own "Best of HN" magazine or really, any "Best of" magazine.

Thats nice. Will be helpful for others to start from where you left.

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#47
post #45

A real shame. Hacker Monthly was a great product for the HN community and I'm going to miss it arriving in the post every month. With that said, I think there's still a healthy ecosystem of similar products. There was a post on the front page about a new newsletter that sent out one "classic" HN post a week, I think the article mentioned it was doing pretty well. Can't remember its name though haha.

You're thinking of HackerCanon: https://medium.com/swlh/best-of-2015-pfffffffft-79d9b014f4de

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#49
post #48

Out of curiosity, did Hacker Monthly print articles from the web? With permission of the source websites?

Hacker Monthly put together a physical magazine (it looked gorgeous) full of articles from Hacker News.

(Source: he asked my permission for a post of mine that got some attention back in 2013.)

Re: Hacker Monthly Shuts Down

#50
post #25

I wod love to hear from the OP if he had explores transitioning, aka selling, this to someone. I think there is a market for the attention of people with money to spend, even in print magazines (especially in niche print magazines). But maybe he explored it and didn't find any takers, or maybe he doesn't want to deal with the hassle of such a transition. Would be nice to know.

As other comments have pointed out, not having the subscribers list is my non-negotiable terms if someone wants to take over. In fact, after I refunded everyone, I'll reset my server and remove all my DB backups so I won't even have a copy of it. I know it doesn't make business sense for someone to buy a business without any customers. That's why I never explore the option of selling it.

That's an interesting choice. I'm sorry, I scanned the blog and didn't see this mentioned. It certainly creates a higher hurdle for a sale.

I'm sure you've considered all the options, but may I ask why you didn't choose to offer current subscribers an 'opt-in' option for being contacted by a new publisher? That way those who were interested in continuing with a new owner would be able to, and those who were only interested in your product wouldn't be bothered. (Again, I wasn't able to find the blog post where you mentioned being approached by possible owners, so if you answered this question there, I apologize.)

But if you open source everything (as mentioned in another one of your comments), that'd be great too.

Post reply on HN