Live data from Hacker News

“Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

paulgraham.com

1–10 of 63 posts

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#2
I agree with this sentiment in general, especially that our own feeling of self-worth can be determined to a fair degree by the opinions of people we surround ourselves with, and that this drives conformity.

However, I'd add an important corollary, and one that is perhaps a bit less cynical :). Even if it's mostly true that you can only feel fulfilled when your actions and opinions are approved by your peers, you still get to chose who your peers are, and whose opinion you value. That's true today more than ever, with the world's interconnectedness and the huge diversity of on- and offline communities.

Near the end of the article, Mark Twain says "Men think they think upon great political questions, and they do; but they think with their party, not independently." If you take the time to choose the parties/communities you align yourself with carefully, you can live a very principled and self-determined life even accepting the inevitability of some degree of group conformity.

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#3
I like how Emerson felt about conformity, not to mention - to be exceptional, one must be a non-conformist. Many would rather be accepted than exceptional At some point in your life, you may have to make that choice.

The problem with public opinion in our times is this idea that the crowd is always right. Something is true because the crowd says it is. The crowd saying it is, makes it true. Sane is not the same as true. Sane just means many people believe it. The person who believes something no one else does is considered insane. When the lone "insane" person is vindicated, great wealth and success seem to follow.

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#4
Here's what I have to say about that: That's pretty rich, coming from you, Paul Graham.

You have All The Money, and All The Respect amongst your large and powerful peer group. Given your considerable wealth, there's nothing anybody can do to negatively impact your life in any meaningful way. Yet you continue to bang the same drum you've been banging for a decade now, at least.

Time to tell us something we don't already know.

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#6
post #3

I like how Emerson felt about conformity, not to mention - to be exceptional, one must be a non-conformist. Many would rather be accepted than exceptional At some point in your life, you may have to make that choice. The problem with public opinion in our times is this idea that the crowd is always right. Something is true because the crowd says it is. The crowd saying it is, makes it true. Sane is not the same as tr…

>When the lone "insane" person is vindicated, great wealth and success seem to follow.

I must not have been paying attention. When did that ever happen?

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#8

Here's what I have to say about that: That's pretty rich, coming from you, Paul Graham. You have All The Money, and All The Respect amongst your large and powerful peer group. Given your considerable wealth, there's nothing anybody can do to negatively impact your life in any meaningful way. Yet you continue to bang the same drum you've been banging for a decade now, at least. Time to tell us something we don't alrea…

Paul Graham didn't write it.

Re: “Corn-Pone Opinions” by Mark Twain (1901)

#9
And it readily brings the famous Nazareth's evangelist to mind- Jesus Christ.

Considering the 6 stages of his blasphemy trials between Religious and Roman courtrooms (especially, the burdened denial of right and wrong between Herod and Pilate).

And contrasting that unfortunate crisis of conscience greeted by the reported mob justice with how many billion people today follow a religion borne of Christ's personality, it just reinforces one thing Mark Twain endeavored to deliver as important message in that essay:

"Think for yourself."

Post reply on HN