Live data from Hacker News

Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

engadget.com

161–170 of 175 posts

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#162
post #133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think so. Kindle targets people reading stuff, this targets people interacting with stuff. That's a fundamental difference and e-ink lends itself to reading much more than to interaction. Also, the kindle has a battery life that this device can't hope to match and works well in various light conditions.

Sure.. but it's ugly next to the iPad and as Steve Jobs has proved time and time again looks count. At a $499 starting price this might not kill Kindle but it will take a huge bite out of its market. There is clearly no doubt about that. EDIT: I am a Kindle owner btw.. I even wrote a blog post defending it against the new Apple tablet but after seeing this I have to change my mind. I had no idea that Apple was pursui…

There's a kindle reader for iPhone, right? Won't that work on the iPad?

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#163
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're halfway smart and not just one of the 'I got it first' crowd I'd advice your credit card to solidly cling to the inside of your pocket for the next 6 months. Let others deal with the inevitable 1.0 bugs. When dealing with new technology second best is best.

Apple's history with the iPhone/iPod though is that the hardare is generally pretty good at launch and all bugs are in the software/firmware which can be fixed. It won't be a business critical tool for me - I will happily deal with some of the teething issues. Still want one ;-)

There were quite a few hw related problems with early iPhones, off the top of my head, 3G issues, battery life, screen tint (not sure if that one was device or firmware related), touch screen dead zones.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#164
post #142

Pretty amazed there is apparently no front camera. That's the wow moment I was waiting for.

I'm really disappointed. I was looking forward to being able to easily move around from room to room while video chatting.

Apple brought nothing new to the table today. They didn't solve text entry on tablets, they didn't make it easier to video chat (or even voice chat for that matter), and they didn't come up with a new form factor that is better than a big flat slab of metal.

It's bad when the biggest wow moment for a product is the price and data plan.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#165
TBH, the only thing I can see this being more useful for than a netbook is reading ebooks, as I don't watch movies on my computer. And given that all it has is a standard, all be it nice, display I wouldn't buy one. E-ink is far superior for reading. I can see it being useful for grandma who can't remember how to right click, but given the closed nature of the device, no thanks. The hardware looks ok, but not spectacular. Not that that will stop Apple from making a boat load on them. At this point, Apple could sell rotting fruit and people would rave about how great it is and buy it by the truck load.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#166
post #148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Motorola doesn't do semiconductors anymore, they spun that off to Freescale. Also, Apple bought chipmakers PA Semi a few years ago. The Apple A4 CPU is probably built by the former PA Semi.

PA Semi is fabless, right? So who's knocking out all these A4 processors for iPads?

According to rumors, TI used to do PA Semi's fabbing.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#167
post #131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

3G, decent processor, Mac OS X instead of iPhone OS, front camera...

> Mac OS X That would have been a bad thing with a touch screen IMO.

so because of touchscreen let's deprive users of everything else, like multitasking, freedom to install anything etc etc.?

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No phone. Less computing power than a MacBook. Lame.

In case anyone missed the reference: http://apple.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=01/10/23/1816257&#3...

That's a solid reference for some perspective.

I too am underwhelmed with it, but this is just the 1st version of a new /platform/. They can add all kinds of things later.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#169
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Between my desktop, macbook and iPhone...

Except this doesn't replace any of those...

The point is that not everybody even has all of those. What you're really saying is that your desires are all fulfilled, not that you don't have the desires that the iPad purports to fill.

Re: Live from the Apple 'latest creation' event

#170
post #160
post #124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you be a little more specific as to what would have met your expectations?

I was personally hoping for a new user experience. I want a tablet like Microsoft's Courier prototype. It's a book, which can easily be held with one hand. You interact with it in fundamentally different ways than both a phone and a laptop. It serves an entirely different purpose. The iPhone works because I can operate it with one hand. They effectively took the iPod Touch and scaled it up... this left me underwhelme…

I want a tablet like Microsoft's Courier prototype.

This is why Apple doesn't do concepts and prototypes anymore. There is undoubtedly someone at Microsoft wincing every time someone says something like that, seeing as how they don't have a product to sell you along those lines in spite of being on their third try at tablets. (I don't mean that at a jibe at you at all--what you say is perfectly reasonable!)

People are going to compare the iPad with other tablets/laptops

True, but I'm not convinced that everyone will do so and that those who do will not decide in favor of the iPad.

I mean, it compares in some ways to smart phones, netbooks, laptops, gaming portables, eBook readers, and media players. Obviously it's not going to be the best at everything, but I think it stands a good chance of being a successful blend--Apple won't win everybody, but they might win a respectable share over from each. A $500 laptop or netbook might "do more", but is the battery life there? Is it pleasant to curl up in bed and read on? Do people want Windows or do they want the App Store? The Kindle DX is about $500. Are people going to weigh e-ink against everything the similarly-priced iPad does? Is someone looking at a $400 iPod Touch going to reconsider the importance of portability?

Post reply on HN