Live data from Hacker News

The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

i.gizmodo.com

81–90 of 115 posts

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#81
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

however, all model are shipped as GSM unlocked so there's nothing stopping anyone from signing up with another GSM provider.

But do we know which 3G bands it supports? i.e. for American users will it work on t-mobile 3G?

I would assume so, unless T-Mobile uses a different GSM freq from international carriers. They don't want to have to make separate hardware for the international market.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#82
post #74
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, Apple didn't promise much. The lunatic media did.

isn't "lunatic" media the result of Apple marketing?

No, it's the result of lazzyness of "journalists" who don't want to do research and come up with real content by themselves.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#83
All the flash (or lack there of) got me excited, but there are a few glaring questions left unanswered:

1) Support for multi-tasking? This is a must on something like this. Perhaps they want to ensure performance of single applications by restricting multi-tasking?

2) Flash support? When Steve was browsing the flash plugin was missing... another must on a device that is trying to act as an intermediary between laptop and phone, primarily for web usage.

3) All of the focus on the iPad as an e-reader is neglecting the fact that the screen will be difficult to read off of. The screens of Kindles and Sony e-reader products are the major attraction, in my opinion. There's no way I could read for several hours on a backlit screen.

It's a great multimedia device, and has some awesome practical implications. However, I think the things I listed above are big time issues for the intentions of this device.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#85

It seems their main target is the macbook-buying college student. I wish this thing doesn't cost more than 499 ($599 max).

A college student with a MacBook is NOT going to get this. They lug around a computer already, what's the point of lugging an ipad around too?

I was talking about the soon-to-be college students, not the soon-to-be-graduating ones.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#86
post #78
post #19

Yeah - it's a big iPod. yawn As an instant-on, full-page web browser, it's far more useful than a netbook, but it's pretty underwhelming for everything else. With shorter battery life, greater cost, and more eyestrain than the Kindle, I doubt it will have much impact on the e-reader market.

How many do you think are going to look at the Kindle at $250-500 and then the iPad at $500 and choose the single-purpose-does-one-thing-somewhat-better device? If Amazon dropped the price to sub-$100, I think they'd sell them by the boatload, but at current price points... nah.

$500 is still twice $250, and at twice the weight of e-reader... I'm not compelled, especially with iPhone OS and App store limitations.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#87
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

you can have root on a netbook...

How many of your average computers users really care about that? If I can access a shell and write some code on this thing, I'm sold. The battery life alone is worth it. Edit: Sadly reading this thread is like reading Slashdot about the announcement of the iPod.

>| How many of your average computers users really care about that?

I'm sorry, but this is a terrible argument. None of my users care about having root on our file server either, but if I didn't have it, it wouldn't be useful as anything more than a very expensive paperweight. Most readers probably don't care if the authors have access to a typewriter, but they depend on that to be able to read books.

Similarly, most iPad users won't care about having root on the thing, but they shouldn't. They people that do care about this are the developers, and the work of the developers becomes the tool of the masses. The complaint about this thing not being open is that apple is restricting what sorts of tools can be made. While the end-user might not care about the specific mechanism of restriction, they do feel its effects.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#88
post #24

Starts at $499. Suck that, netbooks.

My netbook was $279 with a 6 cell battery and a 160GB harddrive. That's throw away money! But at $499 for 16GB that's not really in the same market.

You also forgot that you can run office and other productivity software on it, photoshop, use it for live performance music mixing, composing, play real games, don't need to dock it to have a real keyboard and mouse and can plug in a DVD burner to watch more movies, etc. etc. etc. etc.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#89
post #24

Starts at $499. Suck that, netbooks.

Why does 3G need to cost $130 extra though? Is the component that expensive, or just a way to capture more value from customers who can afford it?

Apparently the 3G version also has a GPS unit built-in.

Re: The Apple Tablet Is Here, And It's Called the iPad

#90
post #79

It seems like it will be excellent for for salesmen or pharmaceutical representatives. Personally, I'm fighting whether I should continue with my Kindle DX purchase, or get this instead.

I was in the same boat. I went with the DX. Not making my eyes bleed after all day looking at lcd screens, transfer things with usb, (don't need iTunes), and last more that one day on a single charge made my choice easy.

This device looks interesting, and might open up new use cases, but I'm not interested in going back to a walled garden.

Post reply on HN