Live data from Hacker News

I Turned Off JavaScript for a Week

wired.com

91–93 of 93 posts

Re: I Turned Off JavaScript for a Week

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If not ads what do you want? Paywalls? Native content? Personally I want a robust and diverse web ecosystem, not just pay walls and people forced to alternative revenue sources.

> Personally I want a robust and diverse web ecosystem Well, everything paid for by ads is the opposite of diverse. Pretending paywalls are the only alternative is disingenuous too. There's plenty of options, like donations, or Blende's "pay per article, get your money back if it sucks" model, which seems to work well

They don't work well in most cases. You can point to some very specific niche markets where donations and pay per articles work. Just look at Patreon, its a great service and I use it to support a few things. But its not going to support most businesses.

For most business its going to be either a paywall or ads and ads allow for content to be access by people without means to pay for it.

Re: I Turned Off JavaScript for a Week

#92

This is where I draw the line, Hacker News. The end of the road. Do you know how many shitty stink eyes I've gotten from people on this site, just because I've dared to speak out against JavaScript, Cookies and Analytics. But oh! OH! Wired writes a story about it, and suddenly, the clouds open, and the sunshine just pours through. *OF COURSE* an article in *Wired* is gospel! We were *FOOLS* to ever claim otherwise! J…

It's not how I'd phrase it, but I agree. It's appalling how many people on HN seem to think that it's perfectly okay to require JavaScript in order to display text.

Re: I Turned Off JavaScript for a Week

#93
post #65
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I understand the intent of your post, don't most people minify (obfuscate) their JS code to reduce bandwidth costs (on both ends, user and company)? Even in todays high bandwidth availability age we still use CDNs and the like to reduce such a cost. That said, it would definitely be nice to see non-minified versions of code we run in our browsers available as open source by the company serving it. It's not like…

You only save bandwidth the first time the resource is accessed. After that it's loaded from the browser cache! So over time, the band-witch saving by minification is insignificant.

The first time the resource is accessed is the most important. You have precious few seconds before the user instinctively reaches for the back button.

See http://www.fastcompany.com/1825005/how-one-second-could-cost... and other similar articles.

Post reply on HN