Live data from Hacker News

Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

spectrum.ieee.org

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#31
post #28

Not only. In Italy there is a toy that explain the BCD (Binary coded decimal) with colored tiny balls. http://www.quercettistore.com/prodotti/rami About 30 years ago.. Sorry but this not happen only in Silicon Valley.

I don't think this is coming out of Silicon Valley:

play@primotoys.com

+44 (0) 740 0549 759

Unit T, Reliance Wharf

London

N1 5ET

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#32
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Scientific research quite strongly links excessive screen time to psychological problems in children. You can be spared from science, if you'd like, but it does no good to ignore real problems just because you want to stick your head in the sand. Edit: And for the bogeyman's sake, if you'd like the "proof", that's what Google is for. This isn't some fringe view. It's about the same as asking me for proof that smoking…

Correlation != causation. Is screen time per se that would create some issues with kids, or is it the lack of real communication between parent and kid? I love to sit down and actively watch (i.e. point, name, discuss) a show with my 3 y/o son. When not excessive, I feel this is good for both of us.

> When not excessive, I feel this is good for both of us.

While I also agree that it doesn't feel wrong to experience something on a screen as a family, we should always be wary of "it feels good/right" as a reason for believing that something isn't bad for you in the long run. That's a slippery slope that has led to plenty of negative trends recently. It's far too easy for people to latch onto things that are good in moderation and let those things slip into over-saturation.

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#33
post #11

So it's Robot Turtles IRL? My kids dig Robot Turtles and would have fun with this.

For those who don't know, Robot Turtles is a board game that teaches programming concepts aimed at young children that you can pick up at Target or Amazon for like $25, for those of you who are balking at the high price of these robots.

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#34
post #27
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yes how dare they spend their money on their first born!

If they want to spend money on their first born, there are far better, more rational ways to do it. $199 in a 529 plan turns into $2k by college time. $199 in used clothes or legos will go a lot further at that age.

I believe programmable lego starts at $300 or more.

I also don't think the people who buy this buy it as the only toy for their kid. They probably already have spent plenty on other stuff.

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#35

> My main objection to pushing STEM down to the diaper set is that it all seems to involve screen-based learning tools, and I am sure that little ones don’t need more screen time. This thing seems pretty cool. On the whole, we probably need to have more of an awareness of how important tactile and spatial factors are in child development. But the top selling point, according to this reviewer, is that it protects your…

Scientific research quite strongly links excessive screen time to psychological problems in children. You can be spared from science, if you'd like, but it does no good to ignore real problems just because you want to stick your head in the sand. Edit: And for the bogeyman's sake, if you'd like the "proof", that's what Google is for. This isn't some fringe view. It's about the same as asking me for proof that smoking…

I've looked at Google and PubMed and was not impressed by what I found. Most "screen time" studies are primarily or exclusively TV-watching studies, and in many cases are in turn using that as a proxy for sedentary behavior in general rather than actually examining media consumption patterns. In short, they don't demonstrate that all screen time is equivalent, they just define the variable that way. That can be entirely justifiable from a study design standpoint, but also limits what the results can tell us.

The main source for recommending limitations on overall screen time for young children seems to be a set of recommendations published by the American Academy of Pediatrics [1], but they don't actually cite any research (or their citations are too well-hidden for me). The AAP recently published a release stating that new recommendations are coming soon and suggesting that the old guidelines are unnecessarily rigid and unrealistic, even to the point of explicitly stating that "The public needs to know that the Academy’s advice is science-driven, not based merely on the precautionary principle.". The top bullet point is "media is just another environment". This newer document generally advocates a nuanced approach that takes the nature of the content or activity as well as the social context of media consumption (e.g. whether parents are actively watching with the child) into account [2].

[1]: https://www.aap.org/en-us/advocacy-and-policy/aap-health-ini...

[2]: http://www.aappublications.org/content/36/10/54.full

Re: Teaching a 3-Year-Old to Program Without a Computer Screen

#36
post #27
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yes how dare they spend their money on their first born!

If they want to spend money on their first born, there are far better, more rational ways to do it. $199 in a 529 plan turns into $2k by college time. $199 in used clothes or legos will go a lot further at that age.

at some point you need to come to grips with the fact that some people are just wealthier than you, and don't really care about that $2k in 18 years because they or their parents, or grand-parents, or great great great grand-parents already solved that pesky 'lack of money for the kids' issue.

you're projecting your own financial situation onto others in the demographic buying disposable $180 doo-dads for their kids.

it's like getting mad at the rain.

Post reply on HN