Live data from Hacker News

Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

teenvogue.com

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#11

Some people are more attractive, cooler, more interesting, than others. It's not some evil plot by the corporations to make us feel bad about ourselves. These people are really out there. The left wing narrative that all bad things that happen to us stem from some structural power imbalance in our society, is blind to this fact of nature. So they need strange stories like this to explain away the apparent differences…

[deleted]

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#12
post #4

She's trying to create a movement out of it: http://www.letsbegamechangers.com . I'm not sure how I feel about this, if it's sincere and genuine or just a marketing ploy. Hopefully the former.

Wow. Is she advocating for complete removal of social media from the web? Good. It has done nothing good for anyone.

Other than help start revolutions in the Middle East.

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#13

She had to pose is what I'm getting from this. Granted, I'm not one of those people who thinks modelling is simple, but I'm not following what is severely dark about that.

If you read the captions you'll see a bit more. It's not about the posing, it's about the dieting and the fraying relationships with others.

Modeling has its own dark side but it's a job in which you work with co-workers. You're not getting your sister to take the shots. You're not disrupting family life in the same way. You also aren't actually graded on popularity and "likes" in the same way -- your job goes well or poorly and certainly since it's about appearance you get all the food disorders and etc, but there's still a level of remove. Someone else is taking the pictures and telling you what to wear and how to stand. The creative endeavor is not all on you. This girl, by contrast, was not just the person who posed but the one who set up the shots, had the sister take them, watched the "ratings," did the testing on what people liked, etc. On the one hand, that complete "creative control" is cool. On the other hand, she was very literally chasing the approval of others.

I think they probably skimmed right on over some of the really dark parts, like the restricted eating and insecurity that this sort of externalized approval processes would cause in most 15-year-olds. Some of us old people do weird s(tuff) when a high-school reunion is coming up, and we are supposed to be mature and grounded. Haha. But remember, that 15 is definitely an age where you have a somewhat more limited idea of the scope and shape of a good life.

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently it took over her life, became an obsession. Social media made it easy to collect acclaim and popularity on a massive scale. Massive compared to what physical, real life offered.

Right, so like modelling, which is not exactly an obscure occupation. That she did it using instagram doesn't make much difference there. I think it's important to point out that I am an old man, not a teenager, so overdramatizing things doesn't boost my engagement.

Modeling is not an obsession, it's a job. You do it when you're young, smoke a lot of cigarettes etc, and then you move on. It's like grad school but with even more skeezy old guys.

(Now, math modeling may become an obsession...)

edit: just to be clear, oldmanjay, I am not making any comments about old guys in general! some of my best friends are old guys!

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow. Is she advocating for complete removal of social media from the web? Good. It has done nothing good for anyone.

Other than help start revolutions in the Middle East.

It collapsed two countries and nearly got a third but ended with exchanging one dictator for another. How is Tunisia these days? The origin gets overlooked with the rest of the shit show going on.

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#16
post #4

She's trying to create a movement out of it: http://www.letsbegamechangers.com . I'm not sure how I feel about this, if it's sincere and genuine or just a marketing ploy. Hopefully the former.

Wow. Is she advocating for complete removal of social media from the web? Good. It has done nothing good for anyone.

Not sure if this is sarcasm. Job opportunities, facilitating protests/revolutions, artistic collaborations, ...

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow. Is she advocating for complete removal of social media from the web? Good. It has done nothing good for anyone.

Not sure if this is sarcasm. Job opportunities, facilitating protests/revolutions, artistic collaborations, ...

Not at all. See my reply to your sibling comment. Add to your list massive government and corporate spying.

Re: Instagram-Famous Teen Shows the Dark Backstory of Her Perfect Selfies

#19

Some people are more attractive, cooler, more interesting, than others. It's not some evil plot by the corporations to make us feel bad about ourselves. These people are really out there. The left wing narrative that all bad things that happen to us stem from some structural power imbalance in our society, is blind to this fact of nature. So they need strange stories like this to explain away the apparent differences…

You'd don't think corporations use marketing to intentionally make people feel bad about themselves?
Post reply on HN