Ask HN: New attempt at mobile markup – keep or bail?

Keep - old Nexus 4

Thank you for making this. My one suggestion would be to make the upvote/downvote arrows larger and farther apart. I'd say around 5% of my votes on mobile are incorrect. Often I'm lazy about zooming in to make sure I hit the correct arrow.

Actually, I'd like that change on larger devices as well. I've often misvoted on my Surface. As large touchscreens become more popular (iPad Pro, the Surface line, etc), I could see this becoming a problem for more users.

Edit: I see white margins on my iPhone 5, but not on my iPhone 6. It looks like you need to tweak the media query in the following css:

    @media only screen
    and (min-device-width : 375px)
    and (max-device-width : 667px) {
    ...

The iPhone 5's device width is 320px. Changing that 375 to something lower should fix the issue.

Finally! please don't bail. But the homepage in iPhone5S (and maybe all iPhone4.7 inch) doesn't take full width as in iPhone6. Here is a screenshot ==> http://i.imgur.com/bMcUcjU.png

Good point. So let's talk about that upvote arrow next... =)

Definitely a step in the right direction, but very difficult to read. The font is far too small and all links are similarly too small to allow easy tapping.

This comment form could also use work. It doesn't fit the width of the screen, so I have to pinch/scroll to see what I've written then maneuver back to type. Nor does it auto expand or allow manual resizing. Just trying to scroll risks pull-to-refresh in Chrome for iOS or some embedded WebKit browsers.

I'd also say the navigation could be addressed. The first comment about sizing is a start, but the separate site and account navigation lists don't have enough space now, let alone once you up the font. Some sort of collapsing/hidden/drop down menu might need to be considered if you intend to keep 8 independent links with sufficient padding for accurate tapping.

A good start, but still not there IMO.