Live data from Hacker News

Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 46 posts

Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#1
Can anyone help with this? From what I've gotten from google I'm meant to contact PG somehow.

It's not exactly clear how and if there's some channel I can use that doesn't clutter his inbox I'd like to try that first.

Edit: Thanks for the tip - title changed, hopefully that helps.

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#3
I'm not even sure if that possibility exists but since your account does not seem to be attached to anything personal as far as I can see and since you have barely posted / commented here what is the reason you want it deleted ?

Keep in mind that deleting an account means that all the replies to your comments / submissions would be left 'hanging' in space.

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#4
post #3

I'm not even sure if that possibility exists but since your account does not seem to be attached to anything personal as far as I can see and since you have barely posted / commented here what is the reason you want it deleted ? Keep in mind that deleting an account means that all the replies to your comments / submissions would be left 'hanging' in space.

I don't know about the US, but over here in the Netherlands any service must respond to a request to remove your records. They must comply, or provide a very good reason why your comments/submissions must remain. (In discussions comments can stay if required for the discussion to make sense, but the name has to go).

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#5
post #4
post #3

I'm not even sure if that possibility exists but since your account does not seem to be attached to anything personal as far as I can see and since you have barely posted / commented here what is the reason you want it deleted ? Keep in mind that deleting an account means that all the replies to your comments / submissions would be left 'hanging' in space.

I don't know about the US, but over here in the Netherlands any service must respond to a request to remove your records. They must comply, or provide a very good reason why your comments/submissions must remain. (In discussions comments can stay if required for the discussion to make sense, but the name has to go).

His name isn't there, it's just a non-specific alias.

I read it to mean 'dave australia', if he is actually called 'dave au' then that's slightly different.

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#6
post #4
post #3

I'm not even sure if that possibility exists but since your account does not seem to be attached to anything personal as far as I can see and since you have barely posted / commented here what is the reason you want it deleted ? Keep in mind that deleting an account means that all the replies to your comments / submissions would be left 'hanging' in space.

I don't know about the US, but over here in the Netherlands any service must respond to a request to remove your records. They must comply, or provide a very good reason why your comments/submissions must remain. (In discussions comments can stay if required for the discussion to make sense, but the name has to go).

HN is not in the Netherlands, so this is completely irrelevant. (Just like when some company in the US sends a DMCA takedown notice to the Netherlands.)

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#7
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know about the US, but over here in the Netherlands any service must respond to a request to remove your records. They must comply, or provide a very good reason why your comments/submissions must remain. (In discussions comments can stay if required for the discussion to make sense, but the name has to go).

HN is not in the Netherlands, so this is completely irrelevant. (Just like when some company in the US sends a DMCA takedown notice to the Netherlands.)

He wasn't implying that Dutch law was valid in the US, he was simply stating that because perhaps there is some similar law in the US (hence the "I don't know about the US").

Besides, does one really need to provide a valid reason to delete an account ? Isn't "just because" good enough ?

Re: Ask PG: I'd like to delete my account.

#9
post #5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know about the US, but over here in the Netherlands any service must respond to a request to remove your records. They must comply, or provide a very good reason why your comments/submissions must remain. (In discussions comments can stay if required for the discussion to make sense, but the name has to go).

His name isn't there, it's just a non-specific alias. I read it to mean 'dave australia', if he is actually called 'dave au' then that's slightly different.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN