Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Salesforce Lightning Design System

lightningdesignsystem.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#13

Post by douche »

debaserab2 wrote: post #12

Wow, this is the first semblance of UX I've ever seen related to SalesForce. The actual product itself, while having a consistent design, is an absolute navigational and hierarchical nightmare for any use case I've had to use it for.

Consistent? Maybe as far as the presentation styling across the application, but the organization of where things are within the app is mind-boggling.

Seriously, I've done some custom Salesforce integrations for some clients, and every single instance has had a different looking admin configuration UI. Things are in different places, the same option is named differently, it's a mess. And this was all on instances that were ostensibly the same release version.

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#14

Post by rzzzt »

csoete wrote: post #5
herge wrote: post #2

Whenever I see corporate-initiated projects like this, I wonder where it will be in 5 years. Open-Source projects that have gained popularity more 'organically' like bootstrap (despite the twitter backing!) seem to be a lot more resilient and more likely to be updated and upgraded as time goes on. Do you really want your SaaS app to look like it was designed in 2015 forever?

Probably targeted at plugins/extensions. At least thats the impression that I get by the phrasing they chose.

It was also mentioned at the time Microsoft's Office UI Fabric project got released. It is very likely that both projects aim to help third party developers get a consistent look, when developing add-ons for their applications.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10147797

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#15

Post by baxter001 »

We ended up asking a third party to theme and provide a grammar over bootstrap for our SFDC front end work, I'm not seeing any great benefit over that (it even similarly requires a special wrapper element to isolate it from the standard SFDC styling.)

Really I'd have preferred that they had contributed a theme for bs3/4 rather than this.

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#16

Post by baxter001 »

douche wrote: post #13
debaserab2 wrote: post #12

Wow, this is the first semblance of UX I've ever seen related to SalesForce. The actual product itself, while having a consistent design, is an absolute navigational and hierarchical nightmare for any use case I've had to use it for.

Consistent? Maybe as far as the presentation styling across the application, but the organization of where things are within the app is mind-boggling. Seriously, I've done some custom Salesforce integrations for some clients, and every single instance has had a different looking admin configuration UI. Things are in different places, the same option is named differently, it's a mess. And this was all on instances tha…

There are now four official administration interfaces you can in theory have with salesforce, one legacy blocky one that requires explicit configuration to stay on, two annoyingly similar layouts of the current production styling and now the "Lightning" version.

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#17

Post by rodriguezartavi »

Started using it in two app exchange apps, actually is pretty good, easy to use.

Yes it's targeted at salesforce new re-design, but that's not a limitation. Actually I am using it both inside of Salesforce as well as an standalone app ( that happens to use Salesforce data )

It's on github, they are answering issues consistently and has a modern foundation.

I am impressed that they pulled this off.

Re: Salesforce Lightning Design System

#19

Post by dalacv »

astrowilliam wrote: post #4
herge wrote: post #2

Whenever I see corporate-initiated projects like this, I wonder where it will be in 5 years. Open-Source projects that have gained popularity more 'organically' like bootstrap (despite the twitter backing!) seem to be a lot more resilient and more likely to be updated and upgraded as time goes on. Do you really want your SaaS app to look like it was designed in 2015 forever?

I am skeptical that this will be kept up to date when a new manager thinks it's "good enough" and takes the wind out of the sails. Or if someone gets laid off that's in charge of the project. If they were to open source this project it would continue to live on even if the original contributors are no longer involved. Open Source always wins in cases like this.

Are you sure you aren't comparing the best open source projects with the worst enterprise projects?
Post reply on HN