Live data from Hacker News

France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

telegraph.co.uk

11–20 of 47 posts

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#11
post #3

This will lead the way so they can start taxing BMW and Mercedes to revive buggy whip manufacturing. Truly visionary.

Haha, very much along the lines of what I was thinking. Isn't the idea behind capitalism that good businesses succeed, while bad businesses fail? What happens when all of the bad businesses are propped up by government subsidies? ^sigh^ whatever happened to letting the market decide...

The tax is to be levied irrespective of the (major) search engine used.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#12
post #3

This will lead the way so they can start taxing BMW and Mercedes to revive buggy whip manufacturing. Truly visionary.

Did you read the article?

What you're saying is analogous to saying our govt't taxing of telephone calls will lead to us reverting back sending smoke signals from Manhattan to DC, or using carrier pigeons.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#13
post #12
post #3

This will lead the way so they can start taxing BMW and Mercedes to revive buggy whip manufacturing. Truly visionary.

Did you read the article? What you're saying is analogous to saying our govt't taxing of telephone calls will lead to us reverting back sending smoke signals from Manhattan to DC, or using carrier pigeons.

I believe that the taxes on phone calls are to pay for the Spanish-American War and not to subsidize the smoke signal industry. If the taxes on phone calls were put into place and the revenues given to the smoke signal industry, then YES I emphatically say that the objective is to lead us back to smoke signals.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#15
post #13
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you read the article? What you're saying is analogous to saying our govt't taxing of telephone calls will lead to us reverting back sending smoke signals from Manhattan to DC, or using carrier pigeons.

I believe that the taxes on phone calls are to pay for the Spanish-American War and not to subsidize the smoke signal industry. If the taxes on phone calls were put into place and the revenues given to the smoke signal industry, then YES I emphatically say that the objective is to lead us back to smoke signals.

Who is the smoke signal industry in the French online advertising tax case?

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#16
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Haha, very much along the lines of what I was thinking. Isn't the idea behind capitalism that good businesses succeed, while bad businesses fail? What happens when all of the bad businesses are propped up by government subsidies? ^sigh^ whatever happened to letting the market decide...

The tax is to be levied irrespective of the (major) search engine used.

But the money is still being used to prop up a market that cannot support itself. If it was a vital service (like maybe a utility service) then I could understand. But we are talking about the music industry!

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#17
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Haha, very much along the lines of what I was thinking. Isn't the idea behind capitalism that good businesses succeed, while bad businesses fail? What happens when all of the bad businesses are propped up by government subsidies? ^sigh^ whatever happened to letting the market decide...

The tax is to be levied irrespective of the (major) search engine used.

He was talking about the "creative industries hurt by the digital revolution" being the ones propped up by this, not the poor search engines.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#18
Also in France we have a tax on CD-R, DVD-R, hard drives, mp3 players which is given to the music companies to compensate their losses from pirating (you pay that tax whether you pirate or not. And still haven't the right to pirate after paying it).

The ISP also give 1% of their income to those companies.

So yes I think taxing the search engines is the logical next step.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#19
post #14

Aren't they just simply proposing to tax online advertising revenue? What's the big deal?

The big deal is that they're planning on using the money generated to support creative industries that are harmed by digital innovation. ie, the music industry.

Re: France plans 'Google tax' on Internet searches

#20
post #14

Aren't they just simply proposing to tax online advertising revenue? What's the big deal?

The big deal is that they're planning on using the money generated to support creative industries that are harmed by digital innovation . ie, the music industry.

But the music industry gets taxed on their revenue, no?

If so, shouldn't the search engines be taxed on their advertising revenues?

Post reply on HN