Live data from Hacker News

Tablet Musings

daringfireball.net

1–10 of 68 posts

Re: Tablet Musings

#3
Not including flash on a tablet seems like a mistake to me. It's one thing on a cell phone, but quite another on a device that will probably be positioned as a casual use computer.

Re: Tablet Musings

#4
I really hope he's wrong about several of these things (no flash, only apps from an app store, full Apple lockdown of everything). Why would I want another iPhone, just with a bigger screen? Especially when it's not clear when I'd use it over an iPhone or my Macbook? I can only handle so much of the Apple totalitarianism, especially if the damn thing costs $1500 or something.

Re: Tablet Musings

#5
The browsing experience will be more of a core thing for the Tablet than for the iPhone. One reason for this is that I expect the Tablet will replace the low-end MacBooks and will need to offer great e-mail and browsing experience.

(Alas) too many sites currently rely on Flash to not include it in the Tablet OS.

Re: Tablet Musings

#6

I really hope he's wrong about several of these things (no flash, only apps from an app store, full Apple lockdown of everything). Why would I want another iPhone, just with a bigger screen? Especially when it's not clear when I'd use it over an iPhone or my Macbook? I can only handle so much of the Apple totalitarianism, especially if the damn thing costs $1500 or something.

Unfortunately - I bet a lot of this is dead on. I can't imagine the device being more open than any other Apple product is.

Re: Tablet Musings

#7

The browsing experience will be more of a core thing for the Tablet than for the iPhone. One reason for this is that I expect the Tablet will replace the low-end MacBooks and will need to offer great e-mail and browsing experience. (Alas) too many sites currently rely on Flash to not include it in the Tablet OS.

Form and function wise I just don't get tablets. I don't seem them replacing MacBooks.

Re: Tablet Musings

#8
post #6

I really hope he's wrong about several of these things (no flash, only apps from an app store, full Apple lockdown of everything). Why would I want another iPhone, just with a bigger screen? Especially when it's not clear when I'd use it over an iPhone or my Macbook? I can only handle so much of the Apple totalitarianism, especially if the damn thing costs $1500 or something.

Unfortunately - I bet a lot of this is dead on. I can't imagine the device being more open than any other Apple product is.

But that's just it...Apple's products vary widely in their degree of openness, from the iPod / iPhone / Apple TV on the end to their computers on the other end. So is this thing more like a computer (you buy it, you own it, hack it to hell and put anything you want on it), or an iPhone (you're basically renting this device from us, and we're going to dictate exactly what you can do with it)?

Re: Tablet Musings

#9
post #3

Not including flash on a tablet seems like a mistake to me. It's one thing on a cell phone, but quite another on a device that will probably be positioned as a casual use computer.

The future isn't flash (IMHO). I think leaving it out makes absolute perfect sense.

It also makes commercial sense - they don't want people playing flash games on the web, they want them buying games from the appstore.

Re: Tablet Musings

#10
I'm amazed that anybody is still expecting Flash. Has the iPhone not conclusively demonstrated that Flash is a legacy feature of dwindling relevance?
Post reply on HN