Live data from Hacker News

Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

huffingtonpost.com

31–40 of 135 posts

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#31
post #4
post #3

Psychedelics can trigger psychosis too.

There is evidence that does not agree with (edit: support) this statement: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/08/130819185302.ht...

While this book is only one anecdote with severe extenuating circumstances - it's a pretty good read.

http://www.amazon.com/And-Then-Thought-Was-Fish-ebook/dp/B00...

It's also online as part of his blog: http://www.stilldrinking.org/the-episode-part-1

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#32
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So... have you known people who've undergone this chemical love carpet-bombing who are tremendously peaceful, between themselves or with people who were not similarly treated? Because I've known a lot of people who used a variety of drugs and many who swore by LSD, mushrooms, ecstasy or a combination, and they weren't a teeny bit less likely to start petty fights over pretty much nothing than the rest of us, nor were…

I've known about thirty people who have used Lsd routinely for years, and I have to agree with you. The only significant difference is that some of them talk like it drammatically changes them. The effect doesn't seem much different from the people I know who really like a hobby and exxagerate its effects. I of course know lsd is something serious and psychedelically powerful, and agree it should be studied.

I am pro drugs. I actually feel most drugs, except antiboiotics, should be available over the counter.

That said, the one drug I have seem people injest, and come back slightly different people is LSD. I have never taken the drug, but I had two close, intelligent friends in high school go off to U.C. Santa Cruz and literally come back different people. We were all so young, and still finding ourselfs, but the differences in their behavior was stark, and didn't go away like I thought it would. I still like both individuals, but we don't hang out anymore.

One friend asked me why we don't hang out any more, and I never told him the truth. The truth is I didn't mind he was different. I didn't hang with the guy because it took him 30 minutes to review a movie, or offer to work on my computer and screw it up; it was this--he didn't have a verbal filter anymore. He would say weird hurtful things, and I couldn't predict when he would say something beyond weird. I just couldn't overlook what he said anymore.

He's actually doing well in the computer industry, and has a family, so maybe it was just me?

(I'm am probally the last one who should comment on Psychadellics, I've never tried them. Even when I went through a reckless stage--Psychidellics scared me. Hell, even marihuana has brought on slight panic attacks. Maybe I'm not psychologically adjusted enough to fool with these drugs?)

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#33
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is evidence that does not agree with (edit: support) this statement: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/08/130819185302.ht...

While this book is only one anecdote with severe extenuating circumstances - it's a pretty good read. http://www.amazon.com/And-Then-Thought-Was-Fish-ebook/dp/B00... It's also online as part of his blog: http://www.stilldrinking.org/the-episode-part-1

Definitely a fantastic read. Terrifying, but incredibly interesting. The author seems like an otherwise fairly well-adjusted person now - but it must be incredibly weird to look back at memories from when you were that completely out-to-lunch.

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#34

They can trigger a paradigm shift in many other areas, not just mental health care. Except it's so hard to explain this to a 'normal' person, who's never taken any. "If God were to permit you a brief voyage into the divine process, let you whirl for a second into the atomic nucleus or spin you out on a light-year trip through the galaxies, how on earth would you describe what you saw when you got back, breathless, to…

Eh this sounds like exactly what was wrong with the early LSD promoters. Psychedelics are the mythical "love bomb"? I do not think the evidence supports that. While I think the world would be far better off if everyone had tried it, I don't think it'd stop wars or anything. At best, it might get people to sit up and think a bit, and turn to rationality for explanations. But in real life, seeing as how one's predispos…

> Eh this sounds like exactly what was wrong with the early LSD promoters. Psychedelics are the mythical "love bomb"? I do not think the evidence supports that.

We really don't have that much evidence - at the one Uni they'd done what, 500 trials with mushrooms over 10 years?

It's obviously not guaranteed to bring world peace, but I honestly think it could make a huuuuuge portion of the public wake up and start asking questions of their leaders.

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#35
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The interviewee acknowledged that, and said people with predispositions to it should not take these therapies. They have reliable screening tests.

How do they work, and how reliable? Seems like a pretty difficult thing to determine which healthy people are predisposed to mental ilness and which aren't.

You have to be skeptical of psychological screening after Lisa Nowak passed some of the most stringent screening out there and still did her diaper drive:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#36
post #27
post #3

Psychedelics can trigger psychosis too.

The interviewee acknowledged that, and said people with predispositions to it should not take these therapies. They have reliable screening tests.

They have reliable screening tests for what?

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#37
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Triggering psychosis != causing longterm mental illness. I think parties on both sides of the debate over the safety of psychedelics would agree that they can and often do trigger psychosis. And both parties probably agree, at this point, that they do not cause mental illness.

How is psychosis not mental illness? You are splitting hairs.

One episode of psychosis is not a life long psychotic illness.

When people say "psychedelics cause mental illness" that could mean:

* Someone with no underlying mental illness takes a few doses of LSD and is left with a life long psychotic illness

* Someone with no underlying mental illness regularly takes huge doses of LSD, and ends up with a life long psychotic illness

* Someone with underlying mental illness has that illness surfaced by LSD use, when it would have gone un-known if they hadn't taken psychedelics

* Someone with underlying mental illness has that illness surfaced by LSD. But it probably would have happened anyway.

* Someone with mental illness has that illness temporarily triggered by LSD.

Because LSD is illegal and it's very hard to research we don't know much about the interactions of LSD and mental illness.

While I'm strongly pro-legalisation I do find it problematic when people dismiss any possible harms of drug use, when it's fine to say we don't know, but should legalise anyway.

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#39

They can trigger a paradigm shift in many other areas, not just mental health care. Except it's so hard to explain this to a 'normal' person, who's never taken any. "If God were to permit you a brief voyage into the divine process, let you whirl for a second into the atomic nucleus or spin you out on a light-year trip through the galaxies, how on earth would you describe what you saw when you got back, breathless, to…

Hmm. Love-Bomb=Ego Loss. Taking that 'to the office' is sustained ego loss.

Most people have big egos. Many people have big ego's and low self esteem or high self esteem. That is the problem, and the ego absorbs the new information.

Once off the drug, that 'paradigm' shift will be integrated into the same type of thinking they had before, except now they are 'enlightened' and act in a superior way because they have seen the light.

You seem to be a seeker, and are not self centered in the way many others are. Do not assume just because you have this experience of the world, men like Jeb Bush, Mao zedong, etc are seekers to a greater truth and will then abide by that. No, they will justify their power seeking behavior.

These chemicals will serve great purpose in practiced medicine, just as they have for tens of thousands of years in many societies. Recreational use vs self medicating might get some people there, but ritualized religious use in the context of insight, healing does work in many cases. But to bring a love bomb upon the globe? Not sure about that

Re: Psychedelics Could Trigger A 'Paradigm Shift' In Mental Health Care

#40
post #8

They can trigger a paradigm shift in many other areas, not just mental health care. Except it's so hard to explain this to a 'normal' person, who's never taken any. "If God were to permit you a brief voyage into the divine process, let you whirl for a second into the atomic nucleus or spin you out on a light-year trip through the galaxies, how on earth would you describe what you saw when you got back, breathless, to…

So... have you known people who've undergone this chemical love carpet-bombing who are tremendously peaceful, between themselves or with people who were not similarly treated? Because I've known a lot of people who used a variety of drugs and many who swore by LSD, mushrooms, ecstasy or a combination, and they weren't a teeny bit less likely to start petty fights over pretty much nothing than the rest of us, nor were…

>So... have you known people who've undergone this chemical love carpet-bombing who are tremendously peaceful, between themselves or with people who were not similarly treated?

It's a horrible idea. Beyond the obvious ethical problems with dosing people without their consent, you aren't guaranteed to have a good experience. In fact a positive experience is probably pretty unlikely if you have no idea what's happening to you or why.

Uses of psychedelics to treat depression or PTSD are happening during a counseling session, and has apparently had some promising results. Although I'm not sure if they've used a comparable length counseling sessions as a control.

Post reply on HN