Live data from Hacker News

YC Research

blog.ycombinator.com

141–150 of 389 posts

Re: YC Research

#141
post #127

> I’m going to personally donate $10 million Statements like this always turn me off. I guess it's because it breaks the illusion that Sam and everyone else at YC are normal people like most of us. They're not. They're INSANELY wealthy by any reasonable standard.

[deleted]

Re: YC Research

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do they have similar policies with regards to openness as YC's research lab?

MSR publish a lot but try to get patents on potentially valuable research first.

Like literally any research organization or university anywhere today.

Re: YC Research

#145
post #12

This thread [0] from couple of days back on Alan Kay's views on recreating Xerox PARC seems relevant. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10322929

We talked to Alan at great lengths in the process of putting this together. He is the most insightful person I've ever met on how to structure an organization for great research.

Is there a talk or discussion somewhere that touches on some of these insights into creating a great research organization?

Re: YC Research

#147
This is the kind of thing Silicon Valley should be doing all the time. I hope Sam's guts is replicated rather than just admired by other investors. Even if it's not, this is a great thing.

Re: YC Research

#148
post #36

I love this idea. Not sure if this is driving your thinking but this would open a desperately needed alternative to Academia if you can scale this idea as successfully as you've scaled startups. I've watched my genius brother-in-law (PhD Materials Science & Chemistry / Biomimicry) be consumed by a very broken UC system over the past decade. Started with an exceptionally bright, curious, and inventive man who created…

Seconded. This is brilliant. As a physics PhD student at MIT who's leaving to build a startup, I'm finding it a relief to leave a broken system.

The academic community is fraught with politics, mismanagement, and inefficiency. Researchers are driven by a need to get published and get grant funding, not to expand the frontiers of human knowledge.

Impact is currently measured by citation pagerank, and broader impact is undervalued. Outreach efforts (blogging, education) are consistently stigmatized [1]. This needs to change.

I would love to see more transparency and accountability in research. I've seen Nature papers continue to be cited despite completely wrong conclusions (the 'erratum' was published as a separate paper in PRL). The arXiv was a great first step at opening up access to papers, but the large publishers continue to hold cartel-levels of control over scientific knowledge.

I'm super excited about YC research. Would love to see a quantum computation division!

[1] http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2011/03/30/...

Re: YC Research

#149
It's an interesting point about fundamental research. The old industrial labs are dead and while academic institutions can do a lot someone in the private sector has to pick up the research mantle. Google X is a good example, but I think smaller efforts like this are much more interesting. If it's done right that is...

Re: YC Research

#150
post #141
post #127

> I’m going to personally donate $10 million Statements like this always turn me off. I guess it's because it breaks the illusion that Sam and everyone else at YC are normal people like most of us. They're not. They're INSANELY wealthy by any reasonable standard.

[deleted]

If he is donating, why should he be obligated to donate it to some other charitable cause? Should humanity only focus on one problem at a time?
Post reply on HN