Live data from Hacker News

Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

bbc.com

1–10 of 32 posts

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#2
I'm absolutely wary of any technology that's going to enable/encourage bullying or trolling. I think there's a fine line between censorship and ensuring a safe community (especially in the wake of the Oregon shooting and corresponding reddit thread), but I see this app leading to Bad Things happening.

That said, the thing I'd like to see the discourse focusing on is not necessarily an app that encourages bullying, but bullying itself. I think the intensity of the uproar this is causing is throwing up a huge red flag - people as really scared about bullying. I think we as a community/country/world should absolutely talk about Peeple, but in talking about the symptom, I hope we can also get to talking about the root cause and what we can do to treat it.

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#4
They really aren't doing themselves any favours here:

'Peeple co-founder Julia Cordray told the BBC: "With any new concept there is naturally fear. "When the people found out that the Earth was round instead of flat and that we revolved around the Sun instead of the Sun revolving around us, naturally people were upset and confused and they pushed back with all that they had.'

Somehow I don't think that the heliocentric model is a useful comparison to make to your idea for a website...

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#5
The PR effort behind this app is amazing. I feel equally intimidated and flummoxed when I try to imagine how they achieved such marketing success. Why did anyone care about this particular app before it started the frenzy, and why does(did?) it continue to grow so much?

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#6
This is alarming, yes. You know what is more alarming? The fact that hardware and websites have conspired together along with brick~mortar retailers, and cell phones, to create an entire profile about everything I do.

Then at some point in the future someone can buy this information. Then some young HR person who has read too many pop psychology books will determine "You're not a good fit" or much, much worse.

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#7
1) Anonymous reviews of real people are unworkable, they descend instantly into the familiar internet culture hell of trolling and awfulness.

2) Nobody wants to write negative reviews of other people using their own real name.

3) Nobody needs a new destination to find faux-positive fluffy reviews of people by other people. To the extent there's demand for that, existing social media does it pretty well already.

Therefore, this will fail quickly and decisively if it launches at all, joining other similar efforts such as Secret and Ello that attempted to solve problems that didn't really exist in the first place with not very well thought out solutions.

Re: Peeple app for rating human beings causes uproar

#8

The PR effort behind this app is amazing. I feel equally intimidated and flummoxed when I try to imagine how they achieved such marketing success. Why did anyone care about this particular app before it started the frenzy, and why does(did?) it continue to grow so much?

I wouldn't really say it's PR, it's more like it just went viral. As in, I wouldn't say the Bedroom Intruder guy or Charlie Bit My Finger had great PR. They just did something that touched a nerve and people pounced.
Post reply on HN