Live data from Hacker News

Meet Model X

teslamotors.com

71–80 of 358 posts

Re: Meet Model X

#71

"Model X is the safest, fastest and most capable sport utility vehicle in history." From any other company I would roll my eyes at the ridiculous hyperbole. Here, it's probably just a statement of fact.

Safest and fastest seem possible, but I'm rather doubting its off road capabilities. Unless of course being capable of driving off road isn't something we expect from an SUV these days.

Re: Meet Model X

#72

Seven seats car seems to address a very small niche.

Yes, not that many have a lot kids, or kids with friends, or visiting grand parents... :)

But yes it is a niche, but not small. There is a lot of 7 mvp cars where I live, Vauhall Zafiras, XC90s etc. And in most of these the third row seats are cramped pop up seats.

Re: Meet Model X

#73

Seven seats car seems to address a very small niche.

Not really. The average family + 1 friend "just" fits in a 5-seater SUV. Having a 7-seater means being able to bring along more than one person. "Hey, we can all ride together!" becomes a very normal part of conversation. Bundle that with the fact that everyone can ride together and everyone saves 100% money on gas, well, it's a no-brainer people will start carpooling more since there are more seats.

Re: Meet Model X

#74
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"It's the perfect SUV for your family + ski gear + showing off just a little bit that you're really wealthy." Gull-wing doors seem less than perfect for transporting ski gear.

Your ski gear goes on a rack on top of or behind the car, both in the Cayenne or in the Model X ( http://www.teslamotors.com/tesla_theme/assets/img/modelx/sec... )

Wonder how rear-mounting compares to top-mounting for overall drag. Anyway, for most users, I imagine you're not driving around with ski gear on your car 99% of the time, so it's a reasonable design decision.

Re: Meet Model X

#75
post #4

> $132,000 for the P90D Signature and $142,000 for the P90D Founder edition [0] [0]: http://www.engadget.com/2015/09/30/tesla-model-x-electric-su...

That is pretty amazing pricing. Most premium families would be looking to the Land Rover Evoque ($41K), BMW X5 ($54K) etc But Tesla is pricing it not to compete with the baseline Porsche Cayenne ($58K) but around the Cayenne Turbo S level ($157K). I guess they aren't planning on building a lot of them.

Additionally, the Model X appears to be significantly faster than the similarly-priced Cayenne Turbo S.

Cayenne Turbo S (the fastest Cayenne model) does 0-60 in 3.8 seconds. [1] The Model X P90D also does it in 3.8 seconds, or 3.2 with the speed upgrade, which costs $10k on other Tesla models, [2] bringing the total Model X price to $152k to the Porsche's $157k.

[1] http://www.porsche.com/usa/models/cayenne/cayenne-turbo-s/ [2] http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/three-dog-day

Re: Meet Model X

#76
post #38

How is that an SUV?

SUV = obese car. This is an obese car, therefore its a SUV. There are snarkier ways, like a car is a vehicle where 75% of the seats are empty almost all the time, whereas a SUV is a vehicle where 85% of the seats are empty almost all the time, so the cutoff is around 80% usually empty. Slightly more seriously a SUV can be defined as a car that has a towing rating approved by the mfgr. I've never owned a car where the…

My Toyota Corolla has a tow rating of 1500lbs, I don't think that makes it an SUV.

Re: Meet Model X

#77

If it's an "SUV" where do I strap my kayak and bike? Mercedes did it better in 1955.

It can tow 5000 pounds - maybe stick the kayak on a small trailer? Or, if you can afford a Model X, buy a used Subaru just for your kayak.

Trailers are a real pain to deal with. A lot of SUVs really aren't but this is an extreme case. I find it a bit ridiculous to call a vehicle an "SUV" if you can't put a roof-rack on.

Re: Meet Model X

#78

Okay.. I'm a Model S owner and I love Tesla and I chuckled at the whole Insane mode and gave a bit of an amused snort at Ludicrous mode. This, however, really makes me wonder WTH is going on there: HEPA Air Filters "There are three modes: circulate with outside air, re-circulate inside air and a bioweapon defense mode that creates positive pressure inside the cabin to protect occupants ." EDIT: Very fair points about…

The car must be reasonably air-tight by itself to make this work, and I imagine there should be a warning signal/siren to driver if someone tries to open a window when this mode is enabled.

Re: Meet Model X

#79
So with the falcon wing doors you couldn't open up passenger seats in your standard garage. I'd suspect people who could afford this wouldn't have a standard garage anyways though.

Re: Meet Model X

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is pretty amazing pricing. Most premium families would be looking to the Land Rover Evoque ($41K), BMW X5 ($54K) etc But Tesla is pricing it not to compete with the baseline Porsche Cayenne ($58K) but around the Cayenne Turbo S level ($157K). I guess they aren't planning on building a lot of them.

See the Model S, which also competes with many, quality sedans from Mercedes, BMW etc.

If you look at pricing the Model S is more competing with the likes of Aston Martin.

Mercedes, BMW are targeting the premium middle class market especially with the new A and 1 series respectively.

Post reply on HN