Live data from Hacker News

Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

motherboard.vice.com

1–10 of 37 posts

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#3
EDIT: DISCLAIMER: See a doctor, don't take this as advise !

“You should never give an antibiotic to anybody, human or animal, unless they’re ill,”

IIRC that is even wrong !

You shouldn't be using antibiotics unless you have good change to get severely sick or develop (long term, or very bad short term) complications (holes in body due to infection, septicemia, ... )

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#4
post #2

Because large agribusiness doesn't actually care if people become ill and die of things like MRSA as a result.

Any other industry and we'd be calling boycotts. Get EU meat only ? http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-05-1687_en.htm

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#7

EDIT: DISCLAIMER: See a doctor, don't take this as advise ! “You should never give an antibiotic to anybody, human or animal, unless they’re ill,” IIRC that is even wrong ! You shouldn't be using antibiotics unless you have good change to get severely sick or develop (long term, or very bad short term) complications (holes in body due to infection, septicemia, ... )

No, when you have a bacterial infection, you need antibiotics. You can easily die from a tooth infection, if not treated. The issue is with prescribing antibiotics to viral sufferers because doctors want to get to the he next patient.

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#8

EDIT: DISCLAIMER: See a doctor, don't take this as advise ! “You should never give an antibiotic to anybody, human or animal, unless they’re ill,” IIRC that is even wrong ! You shouldn't be using antibiotics unless you have good change to get severely sick or develop (long term, or very bad short term) complications (holes in body due to infection, septicemia, ... )

No, when you have a bacterial infection, you need antibiotics. You can easily die from a tooth infection, if not treated. The issue is with prescribing antibiotics to viral sufferers because doctors want to get to the he next patient.

"You can easily die from a tooth infection, if not treated." That would fall under the "long term complication", dead is a bit of a big complication to most.

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#9

EDIT: DISCLAIMER: See a doctor, don't take this as advise ! “You should never give an antibiotic to anybody, human or animal, unless they’re ill,” IIRC that is even wrong ! You shouldn't be using antibiotics unless you have good change to get severely sick or develop (long term, or very bad short term) complications (holes in body due to infection, septicemia, ... )

Honest mistake but you shouldn't give medical opinions on public forums unless you're a licensed medical doctor. You might convince some poor sap to wait until they're septic to see a doctor.

As someone that's been on IV antibiotics, I can tell you that there's no fucking around with bacterial infections and only a doctor (an infectious disease specialist) can evaluate the situation properly.

Re: Why Is It Still Legal to Use Human Antibiotics on Farm Animals?

#10

EDIT: DISCLAIMER: See a doctor, don't take this as advise ! “You should never give an antibiotic to anybody, human or animal, unless they’re ill,” IIRC that is even wrong ! You shouldn't be using antibiotics unless you have good change to get severely sick or develop (long term, or very bad short term) complications (holes in body due to infection, septicemia, ... )

A person who is sick is not competent to be deciding on a course of treatment, unless they are, say, Paul Farmer. See a doctor; follow the doctor's advice.
Post reply on HN