Live data from Hacker News

Why we're leaving Heroku

youbetrayedus.org

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#12
post #10
post #3

Why are the larger tech firms like Microsoft and Apple supporting CISA when they opposed previous incarnations of the bill like SOPA and PIPA?

SOPA and PIPA are not previous incarnations of CISA. CISA has nothing to do with SOPA and PIPA.

[deleted]

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#13
post #12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

SOPA and PIPA are not previous incarnations of CISA. CISA has nothing to do with SOPA and PIPA.

[deleted]

This still is totally unrelated to SOPA.

Also, the blog you linked to is from the same organization that wrote the article we are looking at.

Here is the bill's actual text: https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/234/...

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#14
I followed the link and clicked on the letter from the BSA. I did not see any reference to the CISA in the letter. It seems to be endorsing more restrictions on government surveillance, not less. (at least, thats what the letter claims.)

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#15
post #6

Why are we back here every year, like clockwork? This is what, the 4th incarnation of this bill?

Because government wants control, and while we have to raise a lot of awareness in a short period of time to bring pressure to the politicians on this issue... those who propose this legislation just go back when "Defeated" and rewrite it, put it forward under another name etc.

I believe a lot of the stuff that was "defeated" in the past, got inserted into the recent "net neutrality" ruling that had the internets cheering! (800 pages if I recall, so I didn't read it to find out for sure.)

They will not stop-- law enforcement types have permanent jobs and they're there each year claiming they need more and more control/surveillance.

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#16
If the NSA can't steal the data, then companies will provide the data. Same thing they did with phone "meta" data; shift responsibility to the companies.

This is the new peace. The NSA won't attack your business, and your business will become a part of the national security apparatus.

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#17
post #14

I followed the link and clicked on the letter from the BSA. I did not see any reference to the CISA in the letter. It seems to be endorsing more restrictions on government surveillance, not less. (at least, thats what the letter claims.)

In the section where they are requesting immediate congressional action, they list "Cyber Threat Information Sharing Legislation". This is CISA.

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#19
Look, this "get in touch with your representative / senator" is not going to do it. Can we start mentioning the sponsors and bad amenders of these bills? Nowhere in this letter does it mention the sponsors of the bill. Yeah, the business may loose a little business, but some other damn corp or group will sponsor this bill.

I know in some districts electing a member of the opposite party (and this being a cross-party issue that can be a crap shoot) is not going to happen, but we can work to primary-out the damn fool. The only way politicians are going to listen is if you take their seat away. If you make them fear you if they even think about introducing legislation then you win.

Re: Why we're leaving Heroku

#20
The Paasify link seems to compare Heroku and Pivotal Web Services by default. Note that the last update to that page was 2 years ago, according to the link.

Disclaimer: I work for Pivotal Labs, PWS is run by another division of the same company.

Post reply on HN