Live data from Hacker News

Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

bloomberg.com

101–110 of 115 posts

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#101
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It also feels like Stasi era nonsense. If someone borrows my phone, must I record the call?

Yes obviously, how do you prove it was not you who made the call?

Voice? Being provably somewhere else when the call was made?

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#102
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What? I pay 15€ per month and have 5GB. And when I exceed that I can pay 3€ again to have full speed. ALDI Talk/MedionMobile

O2. 28€ / 5 GB + 10€ "Datensnack" (exceed). The 500 MB thing is a commercial I saw a few days ago "LTE Einsteigertariif" with a flat rate telephone. Actually not that bad, but 500MB LTE... I have a feeling I'll switch soon. I just took O2 because I had a good experience with their prepaid rates, and having checked T-Mobile and Vodafone I didn't find it better.

I've just signed up to WinSIM who are O2. They have some good cheap packages if you are a low user of SMS and calls but do use data. I'm paying €4,99 per month for 1GB. Calls are €0,15 per minute. I've just started so I'm not sure what the catch is yet!

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#103
post #57

Can we shut down GEMA while we're at that?

Why? They are trying their best to collect a fair fee for artists. YouTube are the ones that have decided that those rules shouldn't apply to them and rather than accept those laws they use their own site as propaganda to blame GEMA. What you get presented on YouTube isn't telling the whole truth by any means. It is really annoying as a YouTube user in Germany to have so many music videos blocked, but that is what Google want you to feel. They appear to be doing a very good job of it by the sound of it!

The reality is that GEMA and Google are both acting like children over the matter that has been going on since 2009. Both are to blame but the only thing users see is that it is all GEMA's fault.

The issue needs to be blamed on both.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blocking_of_YouTube_videos_i...

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#104
post #103
post #57

Can we shut down GEMA while we're at that?

Why? They are trying their best to collect a fair fee for artists. YouTube are the ones that have decided that those rules shouldn't apply to them and rather than accept those laws they use their own site as propaganda to blame GEMA. What you get presented on YouTube isn't telling the whole truth by any means. It is really annoying as a YouTube user in Germany to have so many music videos blocked, but that is what Go…

While you're right that the youtube issue is more complicated than "google good gema bad" it's an interesting assessment that the GEMA is trying to collect a "fair" fee for the artist. The GEMA is in dire need of reform on the fair front and on a couple of other issues as well. For example, only the upper 5% of the members get to vote on the distribution of funds, classical music gets ranked higher etc. The goal of the GEMA is a fine one, but over the years the institution has gone somewhat astray.

For german speakers I can recommend http://www.internet-law.de/2012/05/ist-das-system-gema-unfai... as summary.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#105
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, thanks. I know the difference in theory, but reliably mess it up. If more people were to call me on it like you did, it would probably be fixed by now. My American wife never tells me these things and just confirms it when someone else is so nice to point is out. :(

> I live in the US since 8 years and still misunderstood it. in particular it's hard to tell whether you mean 'since I were eight years old' vs 'for a span of eight years' also, a native speaker would probably use tense such as "I have lived", so casually, "I've lived in the US for 8 years and still misunderstood it." and noone ever uses whom, but you probably used it correctly ps you typoed 'possibly be' and 'it'

"no one" is two words, though, confusingly, for all intents and purposes it's a single unit, grammatically.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#106

> as long as they secure the network properly How do I prove it? This right here is so abmahnung trolls can keep on threatening > and get users to agree not to act illegally Yet another useless popup, cookie popup is not enough > ”digital agenda” aimed at blanketing the country with high-speed Internet by 2018 A yeah, "VDSL for all". Where do I buy VDSL modem in 2018? I will have to break into Technisches Museum and…

Why don't you want a Fritz!Box? If the internet comments are to be believed, they are the best routers in Germany. [0] [0] Note: I'm a USian who is rather happy with his EdgeRouter Lite + UAP-AC-LR.

Nothing in particular against Fritzboxes, it's just there is plethora of good producers and devices and I like to have a choice. Fritzboxes are everywhere in Germany, by strange coincidence retailers expose them in the most visible spots, many ISPs promote them heavily by offering them for "free" or very cheap with their subscriptions. In the same time it's quite impossible to buy a plain VDSL modem and most VDSL capable routers cost well over EUR 100.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the point is to clearly shift the moral hazard away from the provider to the user. The user may not uphold the agreement, but then they are clearly the morally wrong party.

Isn't there some meta rule about the first world countries law systems (us excluded) that the only crimes you are responsible for are the ones you personally commited?

Few things: Firstly, this is about civil cases, not crimes. Secondly, the wrongdoing here is allowing someone else to use your internet connection to perform illegal actions, not those actions themselves. Thirdly, in any law system I can think of there are crimes you can commit by literally doing nothing (neglect). For example, in Germany it's a crime to know about a planned murder and not do anything about it.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the point is to clearly shift the moral hazard away from the provider to the user. The user may not uphold the agreement, but then they are clearly the morally wrong party.

Isn't there some meta rule about the first world countries law systems (us excluded) that the only crimes you are responsible for are the ones you personally commited?

Joint enterprise would be one example of someone being responsible for a crime they did not commit.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#109

> providers won’t be held liable as long as they secure the network properly and get users to agree not to act illegally Of course they had to include that paragraph, forcing everyone to tick some stupid check-box. As if the cookie agreements weren't enough already.

They really need some tech-savy people in politics. As long as they don't know what they are doing, we are screwed.

Re: Germany's Wi-Fi Shortage Set to Ease as Merkel Backs New Bill

#110

> as long as they secure the network properly How do I prove it? This right here is so abmahnung trolls can keep on threatening > and get users to agree not to act illegally Yet another useless popup, cookie popup is not enough > ”digital agenda” aimed at blanketing the country with high-speed Internet by 2018 A yeah, "VDSL for all". Where do I buy VDSL modem in 2018? I will have to break into Technisches Museum and…

Why don't you want a Fritz!Box? If the internet comments are to be believed, they are the best routers in Germany. [0] [0] Note: I'm a USian who is rather happy with his EdgeRouter Lite + UAP-AC-LR.

Oh here is my chance to complain about this pet peeve! My provider gives you a Fritzbox with you subscription, I called them a few times that they should use their mass-purchase leverage to demand better functionality but of course the poor support people couldn't make that happen even if they understood what I was getting at :) Fritzboxen are praised across the internet as great routers, but they won't even let you

- change the default host name suffix - assign static host names for internal use - see which device uses how much bandwidth (only the total - yeah great, now I have to hunt for which machine/mobile is uploading all those photos to dropbox) - block machines from the network, and/or throttle bandwidth. It looks like you can do it, but the implementation is useless - yes you can prioritize smtp over http, hurrah! Everything bandwidth-hungry in 2015 goes over http, and then it's all-or-nothing on fritzbox.

Post reply on HN