Live data from Hacker News

OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

optikey.org

31–40 of 91 posts

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#31
This is amazing software and I'm glad something like this is open source. Accessibility hardware often costs a fortune (for understandable reasons) and software isn't typically cheap either. This seems to be very high quality and it has the potential to really improve people's lives. I'm glad things like this exist.

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#32
post #23

I wonder if a version of this for mobile phones could make typing on a phone faster than fumbling with a touch screen.

Mmmm... that was a great deal slower than me using the latest Android swiping support, even counting errors. Can't speak to the other mobile tech stacks, but if you're typing on a phone is slower than that you might want to poke around, you may be missing a technology already installed on it.

(Not a criticism of the excellent work here. It's a fundamental bandwidth problem.)

Concretely: In the time the demo took to write "Meet OptiKey. Full computer control and speech using only your eyes.", I wrote in an Android text area: "I am just typing words as quickly as I can in the android interface. I'm even having to think a bit about it more that I've written so much. uh, hello world? and other stuff. I'm still going and going and going." Including the missing "now" between "more" and "that", and you can't see it but I had to correct 3 words, too. That's about three times faster on the phone I have in my pocket. And let me just say... that is impressive performance for a free eye tracking suite, in my opinion, to still be that fast with just eyes.

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#36
post #2

In the demo, he was quick and he didn't even seem to use much autocompletion. However, I wonder if using a different keyboard layout would be helpful. Dvorak a Colmak, for example, place the more frequently used letters on the home row so you'll spend more time with your eyes there. You can evaluate different layouts with a tool like this: http://patorjk.com/keyboard-layout-analyzer/

I wonder if it really matters with your eyes vs. your hands and fingers. Flicking your gaze around the keyboard seems much easier than moving your fingers around - you'll never have two fingers hitting each other. And on the other end of the speed spectrum, it seems like it's unlikely that this will ever quite be as quick as operating even a QWERTY keyboard with fully functional hands.

If we're talking about what's optimized for eyes and the movement of them, you wouldn't even want a keyboard layout, you'd want something more like a dart board or oval shaped dartboard where the spaces are letters and the most common letters are towards the center. QWERTY is fine for someone familiar with it, like an experienced typist whose already mapped those keys mentally, but I expect someone with a lifelong disability would have no true familiarity with QWERTY (since they can't type) and would have to learn any layout from scratch anyway, so you might as well start from scratch.

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#38
Here is an idea: Tell me if this is stupid:

Assume you have a bunch of HUDs/AACs/Glasses/Whatever that are using this tracking tech. Assume that they are ONLY looking at the real world, not some online data/webpage etc...

There is a camera that either is fwd looking or also 360 looking.

Use the tech to eye track exactly everything that MANY people are looking at to train an AI as to what items in the real-world are important.

i.e. "the ground exists and we know its there, thus its priority in information is low" however "these signs that are being looked at have a higher context priority, and require understanding"

By doing this on a fair scale... you could train AI to use the information of "whats visually important to human navigation" to train them to navigate. This augments what other ML/AI stuff has already been going on...

I do not know if this is basically how self driving cars were developed -- but now that you have a seed of this tracking tech in open source -- it could blossom.

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#39
post #33

This is amazing software, but will it work with me? My left eye is a glass eye and it has little to no movement.

I have a Tobii EyeX and it has the option to track a single eye. You would basically need to set it to track just your right eye, which is a piece of cake in the config (on Windows at least).

Re: OptiKey – Full computer control and speech with your eyes

#40

Could this be covered by existing patents? Tools like these for the disabled are a big business, and patent holders have shut down competition in the past: http://www.disabilityscoop.com/2012/06/14/dispute-ipad-app-p...

This is a good point - how do copyrights protect intellectual property from open source alternatives? I think that this is a really good thing to open-source, but the law can be tricky to navigate. Almost like you need a degree in it...
Post reply on HN