Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 90 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My wife started working for Apple retail a year ago. During training, they asked what an iPad would be used for, and my wife gave pretty much exactly your response -- it's for consumption. WRONG! There was an ad campaign at the time, showing iPads as an important tool in writing music, climbing mountains, etc. They were trying very hard to convince people that iPads were for people doing things, not couch potatoes. I…

Of course you can be productive on an iPad, no question. I have a keyboard-case for it, so writing a few letters or stuff like that is fairly straightforward and without much hassle. It comes down on what "producing" means for you. I am a developer. Yes, I can code even on my iPhone (code editor, ssh client, git client is installed), but i'm much more productive on an actual mac. If you're kinda office worker that us…

The question was what people actually do on an iPad. And the consensus among people who don't get paid by Apple seems to be: couchsurfing.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#82
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The comments that I downvoted turned a little grey and weren't even moved downwards much, so it's probably not that bad for the community. Thanks for your advice, but I find that shoving people's bad behavior right in their face by doing things back to them is a much more effective tool against assholes than just letting them be.

> shoving people's bad behavior right in their face That is not a legitimate way to use Hacker News. Neither is downvoting a good comment because of someone else's bad comments. And I'm dismayed to see that several of your recent comments here have been uncivil. Please don't do these things. If people behave badly because other people do, what hope is there of improving this community? https://news.ycombinator.com/ne…

Talking about downvotes is also frowned upon, so please don't do that either. Thank you.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#83
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> shoving people's bad behavior right in their face That is not a legitimate way to use Hacker News. Neither is downvoting a good comment because of someone else's bad comments. And I'm dismayed to see that several of your recent comments here have been uncivil. Please don't do these things. If people behave badly because other people do, what hope is there of improving this community? https://news.ycombinator.com/ne…

Talking about downvotes is also frowned upon, so please don't do that either. Thank you.

Believe me, I don't like writing these any more than you like reading them. Please just follow the rules so neither of us will have to.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#84
post #67

tl;dr: I use the Galaxy Note 3 for my phone and tablet. I use it because it's got just enough real estate to check out Reddit/Twitter/websites while on the go, but I wouldn't personally recommend it for note-taking. -- I had an iPad for a few years and then sold it somewhere around 2013. I just didn't use it enough, because my laptop was so much more useful for what I was doing, which was mostly coding and writing em…

>I realized I have a Galaxy Note 3 Notice any drawbacks to it, after using it a while?

Some funky problems with displaying certain characters after it's been too long since a restart, but otherwise I really like it. I've probably only used the "S-Pen" a dozen times or so, and the little pen-specific apps can be frustrating to use, but that's a really small part of my use.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#85
post #19

I use an iPad primarily for 3 things 1. Music production/performance. The iPad does few things objectively better than Android and touch responsiveness when it comes to playing music apps is one of them. There's a 100-400ms delay with Android for some reason. I had heard they'd gotten better recently but my girlfriend just got a Galaxy S5 and even though it's a last generation phone it's unplayable for being on time.…

Music production Do you write actual songs on it or rather just work out some melody or beat or so? Just asking becasue I cannot imagine doing the former, especially handling sequencer-style ui's on a tiny screen with touch seems problematic.

Depends on if that's all they know or if they come from a workflow where that's foreign. Or depends on how flexible they are mentally.

I use it mostly as my guitar amps, guitar effects, and drum machine. I have a lot of synths on there that I sequence with a separate app or have someone play with at MIDI keyboard controller. My new favorite thing is to get Xynthesizr (sequencer) in random mode but in a certain key to talk to a synth app and have that be a background bleep-bloop thing that is every changing while I do heavy reverb and echo drenched ambient guitar stuff.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#86

I use an iPad primarily for 3 things 1. Music production/performance. The iPad does few things objectively better than Android and touch responsiveness when it comes to playing music apps is one of them. There's a 100-400ms delay with Android for some reason. I had heard they'd gotten better recently but my girlfriend just got a Galaxy S5 and even though it's a last generation phone it's unplayable for being on time.…

Duet Display looks pretty nice. Does it live up to the performance claims in practice? How's the touch input support? I've been looking for similar software for Android tablets for ages but everything I've tried so far were laggy and unstable. I'll probably end up getting an iPad just for Duet Display if it works as advertised.

I don't know what the performance claims are but it's a bit laggy. Nothing infuriating but I don't know your patience. I don't even touch on it, my mouse cursor moves onto the screen. It didn't even occur to me to touch it while in second monitor mode, I literally treat it as a regular monitor until I stop using it as such.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#87
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Talking about downvotes is also frowned upon, so please don't do that either. Thank you.

Believe me, I don't like writing these any more than you like reading them. Please just follow the rules so neither of us will have to.

If most other people are following the rules, I will certainly follow them. Given that dependency, I can't guarantee anything though.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#88
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lags? How exactly and what is serious work? I have the last non-Air iPad and it still Senna snappy to me. I'm normally pretty critical of UI performance.

Mostly reading, sketching and writing. I couldn't ever get my iPad to work for anything major other than these three things. While individual apps work fine, app switching almost always results in an app-refresh. I'm guessing you have the iPad 3 (the 'new iPad'), which had significantly better specs than the iPad 2 (along with a better screen, I think). EDIT: Just realized I wrote "iPad Air 2", instead of just "iPad…

I have the iPad 4th generation, often forgotten slight upgrade on iPad 3. Both have double the memory of iPad 2, which probably explains the app refresh difference. However, I had the iPad 1 too, and currently have iPhone 4S. Both seemed to get worse with time having been snappy to start with though. We are talking about 4-5 year old devices, possible just more OS functionality and bigger apps use up that memory.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#89
They're great for on lounge/bed browsing. Also for travel to consume media in downtime or work information if you don't have to type too much. And if you have kids they are almost a must for easy entertainment.

As a workstations I don't think they would suit most computer dependent roles.

I'd say overall they are great to have and use mine a bunch, but they're a luxury not a necessity. If you can afford this level of disposable income Id say get a reasonable one and try. Cheap ones tend to lag from reviews and disappoint from performance. If your budget is tight Id put the money into a more quality laptop/phone. Also cost wise tablets tend to last longer than phones in my experience. If you buy a decent one you might get 4/5 years out of it vs 2/3 for a phone.

I'm sticking to iPads for the moment. I use Android and Windows phones so definitely not a fanboy. I would be open to a cheaper Android/Windows if they have improved tablets UX but last Android one I used 12+ months ago didn't seem to work as well as the iPad.

Re: Ask HN: Do you use a tablet?

#90
It's all about use cases. I have many tablets that I use for a variety of purposes. They all fit a certain need.

I have one in the garage that I use as a Sonos (whole-house music system) controller and to occasionally look up shop-related queries (IE - "what is the torque spec on the axle bolt for my bike?").

I have one next to the couch that is also a Sonos controller and I use for weather and "2nd screen" duties. IE - "Why does Con Air's cinematography style look so much like Michael Bay movies?"

I've got one in the home office I use for hacking, many other gadgets I use have tablet-based interfaces.

I have a retina iPad on the nightstand for reading, checking the news/weather/sports/social networks and to control my house lights - part of my bedtime routine.

My most compelling use though is for when I need a light computer for travel. Two years ago, I went to Hawaii for a week on two carry-on bags (including big camera and diving gear). I had my iPad with me and, while there, work had a serious server outage. I was able to SSH into the server, initiate repairs, and get everything fixed while sitting on the balcony in the sun. I did not carry (and could not have fit) any normal sized laptop in the carry on. I also used to it check out various tourist destinations and find places to eat while I was there (which I could have done on a smartphone, true).

I'm an extreme geek, I have embraced the culture of technology, my house is filled with many gadgets that have served me well and others that have served only to drain my bank account. I have no hesitations about buying something if I have even the slightest inkling that it would improve my life/workflow.

In the above, all but the iPads were cheap Android tablets that I dont think I paid more than $200usd for (none of those needs required a whole lot of horsepower).

To speak to your specific interest, tablets are awesome for casual web navigation and almost awesome for note-taking. I have yet to duplicate the ease and awesomeness of a pen on paper for note-taking with any tablet app/stylus combo. Many tablet note-taking apps have great features, but the actual 'feel' of a quality ballpoint pen on wood pulp has yet to be duplicated - for me, I've spent far too much time being 'constrained' by computers to be able to think as freely as I can with a pen and paper. Switching will almost certainly be a painful adjustment. That said, if 'computers' are your native medium, then note taking on a tablet can be a powerful thing.

For example, Microsoft OneNote is an amazingly awesome note-taking app for computer-savvy folks. They really nailed the balance between digital data entry and analog notation while presenting it in a fairly intuitive interface. I've only ever used it on PC, I'd love to see as brilliant an implementation on a tablet. Not sure it's possible without a mouse-'mindset' interface.

Though really, as long as you don't need big horsepower and aren't on an extremely constrained budget, it's not too hard to get your feet wet in the tablet world cheap. I just saw a not-horrible import Android tablet for <$40 on a sale site.

Post reply on HN