Live data from Hacker News

SATA HyperDrive5 RAM Drive

hyperossystems.co.uk

21–25 of 25 posts

Re: SATA HyperDrive5 RAM Drive

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wish people had continued this sort of thing, I had a Gigabyte i-Ram[0] and it was incredible. The most limiting factor was that it used DDR memory slots (maximum 4GB) and the SATA interface. I don't imagine there would be much of a barrier in doing this with more modern technology like PCI-e for the transfers and a big juicy FPGA for addressing substantially more memory. Alas.

Problem is the maximum capacity due to memory controller support more than anything else. But looking at the new NVMe SSD's the bottle neck isn't your SSD anymore and they aren't that expensive if you need those speeds for things like 4K video editing...

Yeah, I like the concept more than have a need for the thing presently. The OPs page talks about a custom spun ASIC so making a controller wouldn't be a huge problem if someone wanted to sink the NRE into it.

Re: SATA HyperDrive5 RAM Drive

#23
post #9

I came across this while looking for a pure RAM USB stick to use as swap on my Raspberry Pi. I didn't find such a beast, unfortunately. I'm also considering sharing some sort of ramdisk via iSCSI from another machine.

Why? The USB bus on the Pi is dead crowded with the NIC, you will suffer from latency issues. Often enough I ask myself why the network chip couldn't be interfaced with MII like any common cellphone SoC does with WiFi and why the USB host pins of the CPU are not routed through to the MicroUSB connector :/

Yeah, it would slow. ;-) Just for kicks, I was trying to figure out a way to break 1GB, beyond using zram swap. I also have an old 256MB Model B that could be more useful with a little more memory.

Re: SATA HyperDrive5 RAM Drive

#24

The only thing this has over an SSD drive is that there is virtually no wear-out. Though I'm not sure if there is a practical workload that would take advantage of this, considering SSDs should be able to handle constant I/O for several years before they die. Is there any other benefit to purchase a HyperDrive over an SSD?

try several months, unless you go with SLC SSDs

Re: SATA HyperDrive5 RAM Drive

#25

Claims "STR of 175MB/s Read and 145MB/s Write", but SSDs appear to be in the 300MB/s to 500MB/s rate: http://www.storagereview.com/samsung_ssd_840_pro_review I would have thought write performance would be faster than SSD, though? are SSD rates really that fast? wow...

FWIW, Intel's latest 750 PCIe SSDs are benching over 2.5GB/sec read speeds if you want to be really blown away :-) http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-750-series-ssd,409...

Same for last generation Samsungs (leader in ssd segment at the moment)
Post reply on HN