Live data from Hacker News

To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

wsj.com

41–50 of 123 posts

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#42
Here's 'one weird trick' that will instantly stop you from procrastinating:

- Schedule the activity

- When the time comes, you'll probably try to think of ways to put it off - ohh the great internal debate: to do, or to punt. Tell yourself that you might as well get started while you rethink your position.

You'll find that you only need to be motivated for about five minutes before you're cruising right along! =)

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#43
post #5

Ok, here's an idea for a procrastination preventer. It's like the ones you've seen already, which you add to your browser, and then they kick you off reddit after 15 minutes or whatever, or blog problem domains entirely. Instead of that, a popup that asks "what are you supposed to be working on right now?" with a short text input. You type an answer, and carry on procrastinating. Then after 15 minutes, it pops up aga…

A simple pop up won't work. At least for me, I tried (simple dialog boxes reminding me I should work off my checklist/To Do).

Maybe inspirational videos/audios?

A Jedi Shia LaBeouf popping up and saying "yesterday you said tomorrow, so just dooo it!" seems like it would work :-)

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#44

I am a remote worker and suffer from chronic procrastination. "Understanding emotions" is an oversimplified solution because many are addicted to procrastination. It's like asking an alcoholic to understand the emotions of why he drinks. I have procrastinated as a student and my entire career and have always gotten away with it. I've been rewarded with praise of my great work, higher paying positions, and bonuses. I…

You've just described myself!

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#45
There is a book that I have found when I had issues with my studies. It helps to understand what lies behind procrastination and how to handle it. Despite non scientific title it is NOT one more time management training. The Willpower Instinct by Kelly McGonigal. http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10865206-the-willpower-in...

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#46
Procrastination is a rational emotional response that the outcome will probably not be worth the effort. Essentially, our body shuts down to conserve energy (resting) until we get to a point (waiting) where we feel a successful outcome is more likely.

This is especially evident in relationships when we put off "difficult conversations." It's not that we don't want to have the conversation (typically we rationally accept the "need" to have it). It's that we fear it probably will not go well. So we procrastinate until the odds are in our favor, either because the effort to achieve the desired outcome has decreased (waiting), or because our total available effort has increased (resting). This is a rational response and strategy toward achieving goals.

The problem of course becomes when the outcome is not something directly within our control, such that there is potentially no amount of energy or time that will make success possible. In these cases, we must "make your own fate" as many say. Or, to put it another way, one must gain leverage over the outcome by changing one's relationship to it.

Thus, the best way to overcome procrastination is to focus on setting outcomes you have control over (e.g., studying for a test vs getting an A), which creates a positive feedback loop since your goals are regularly achieved and thus rationally worthy of additional future effort.

This is also a circuitous way of defining momentum and it's importance stemming from a default to action.

In psychology, it's been shown empirically to be better to praise children for their efforts and actions than praising with identifying language (e.g., "that was a smart thing you did" instead of "you're so smart"). As stated above, this sets a rational positive feedback loop in favor of "smart" actions over behavior, which may include inaction, that successfully perpetuate a "smart" identity.

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#47
This is one of those cases where science, viewed globally, is being dumb.

Is it not consistent with the scientific narrative that procrastination, being a universal behavior, must have been developed evolutionarily for some benefit? It is a pretty sophisticated behavior after all (as the article even describes). So isn't it naive to assume it is a problem to be solved? Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, but shouldn't the early work be in trying to understand the full effects of procrastination on lifestyle and future fitness so that we actually get to a place where we can make judgements about it?

TL;DR: These guys are totally amateur hour.

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#48
post #5

Ok, here's an idea for a procrastination preventer. It's like the ones you've seen already, which you add to your browser, and then they kick you off reddit after 15 minutes or whatever, or blog problem domains entirely. Instead of that, a popup that asks "what are you supposed to be working on right now?" with a short text input. You type an answer, and carry on procrastinating. Then after 15 minutes, it pops up aga…

It only works when i procrastinate using the Computer, which is sadly not always the case.

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#49
post #47

This is one of those cases where science, viewed globally, is being dumb. Is it not consistent with the scientific narrative that procrastination, being a universal behavior, must have been developed evolutionarily for some benefit? It is a pretty sophisticated behavior after all (as the article even describes). So isn't it naive to assume it is a problem to be solved? Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, but shouldn't the e…

Instincts are useful tools for making fast decisions, but in my view we should see them as nothing more than tools. As self-aware beings I see no harm in deciding for ourselves when to follow our instincts and when to override them.

Re: To Stop Procrastinating, Start by Understanding the Emotions Involved

#50
The main emotion involved in procrastination is disgust. A basic emotion that is as strong as fear, but is completely learned and can be attached to every kind of situation, activity or just the thought of starting them.

Procrastination is protecting yourself from feeling the upcoming revolting disgust these activities can bring. You avoid feeling it, like you avoid touching a hot plate, that's why the disgust never shows. Only when somebody forces you to do it anyway.

The (scientifically tested) theory for this is called Anstrengungsvermeidung (german for "effort/stress avoidance") and isn't widely adopted.

Post reply on HN