Live data from Hacker News

Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

techcrunch.com

61–70 of 311 posts

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#61
post #46

In and of itself I really like this move, but I have to wonder if it's good thing in the long run to allow Google to assert its vision of good UX on the entire web. Where's the line? Of course nobody is forcing websites to do anything, but Google is such an important traffic driver it's hard to imagine a site not having to comply to survive.

What's the alternative to allowing Google to rank results as it chooses?

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#62
post #11

I'd really like to see a universal app / site rating service that judges apps / sites on their stability, privacy, security, legitimacy of requested permission, and general UX. It could then provide alternatives to the app / site, and possibly even an anonymous whistleblower service for employees .

This. A Yelp for websites that encourages sites to be good web citizens.

I would like to see a vote based search engine with modified reddit-style searching where a single vote's relevance is a function of its age and the number of existing votes. (but without the post life cycle of reddit where posts drop because of age)

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#63
post #34

Does this apply to "please subscribe to our stupid newsletter" that obscures many sites now?

For those I just enter webmaster@ or even the author's email if that's listed :P

They are probably already subscribed (to test it works). Better to enter a duff@emailaddress.com which will mess up their stats.

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#64
post #55

>Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites That Use Competing Ad Platforms

Not sure why you're getting downvoted. I have wondered this myself. Between punishing sites that are not mobile responsive and this move I wonder if their motivations are partly fueled by the fear that mobile users are spending more times within native apps and not enough time on the web. As you can read here their response to the EU antitrust lawsuit http://techcrunch.com/2015/04/14/internal-google-memo-respon... go…

I think you're right that Google are worried about users moving to a market where they're not relevant. That's why Google have made a point of becoming relevant: they have a mobile OS, a mobile app market, and a mobile app ad platform.

If people move away from web and toward Google's mobile properties, then they're probably pretty okay with that.

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#65
post #33
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a beginner guitarist, this is site is the worst. It's a shame that honest sites like olga.net don't exist anymore.

Oh man I miss olga. I had completely forgotten about it. These "newer" sites are the pits and every single one of them does this BS app install crap. Thank goodness for the "View as desktop" button in mobile browsers.

Do we have an idea about their business model? How much do they pay the music labels for the right to display half-quality tabs? I've always assumed the labels asking for money were the reason why there was so much advertising on those sites and why no plain-text site ever survived.

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#66
post #56

You know, at some point (and we are around that point) Google does cross a line where they are abusing their near monopoly on search. This is a pro consumer move, but it's another instance of Google saying do things our way or we punish you.

But when that happens you can always use....Bing :)

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#67
post #45
post #35

Hopefully Google can distinguish them from the "By browsing this site, you accept the use of Cookies [X]"-popups that EU websites have to implement now.

Site owners should be punished for those banners, as they could refrain from using third party tracking cookies instead.

[deleted]

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#68

Does that mean they'll block youtube? Try playing a video on a phone that does not have the youtube app installed, it's just about impossible to get it right, it's a roulette that's rigged with more than half the links going to the youtube app page on google play. Highly annoying since there is no reason why the youtube page of some video should even have that app installation link at all.

is this true on iPhone as well?

Re: Google Will Soon Start Punishing Mobile Sites that Use Annoying App Install Ads

#70
post #56

You know, at some point (and we are around that point) Google does cross a line where they are abusing their near monopoly on search. This is a pro consumer move, but it's another instance of Google saying do things our way or we punish you.

It's not at all unreasonable that if sites want to be indexed for their content that a search engine penalizes them if they don't display that content prominently once the user lands on the site and instead display some advert orthogonal to what the user wanted.
Post reply on HN