Live data from Hacker News

Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

priceonomics.com

51–60 of 128 posts

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#51

"Supreme Court member Ruth Bader Ginsburg has an honorary degree from every single Ivy League School, with the exception of Cornell, which doesn’t give them out." ...except for her actual undergrad degree, which is from Cornell. (Hey, when you don't have presidents, you take what you can get. And we'll take RBG over several presidents.)

An earned undergraduate degree is not an 'honorary degree'.

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#52

It's just a way to get some press and maybe some money as well. I doubt anyone would be fooled by the title. I went to Oxford, and the arts undergrads there can get an MA OXON 7 years after matriculation (arts courses are generally 3 years, and you don't do anything other than send in a form to get the Master's). I doubt anyone confuses it with the MEng that I got. Using the title is a poncey thing. The last time I r…

I think Germans still place a lot of importance on titles and they still have formal and informal ways of referring to people Du vs Tu

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. Another form of brand marketing. I do wonder how/when these started.

It started as a way to recognized important contributions to a field outside of the academic process.

The article that started this conversation, completely disagrees with you, and they cite the historical record of the early honorary degrees.

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#56
post #14

There should be a distinction between an "honorary" degree awarded because a "real" one would be superfluous (Richard Stallman, Increase Mather, etc) and those awarded because of donations or co-branding.

Stallman is a hugely influential person. He has contributed a great deal to the world of free software. And giving him an honorary degree is a great thing, demonstrating his many accomplishments. But it still really bugs me that he calls himself a PhD, and asks for the title "Dr." (And yes, I have a PhD, on which I worked for 11 years, at great cost to myself and my family. So feel free to take my comments with a gra…

In the UK at some universities ('redbrick' ones like Birmingham and Sheffield) it was possible to earn a Doctor of Science Degree by essentially listing research papers you had published in appropriate journals and writing a critical evaluation of your research field. It struck me that process might suit people like Stallman.

The local Universities in my city award honorary degrees to College principles who sometimes don't have advanced degrees or indeed undergraduate degrees. Further Education colleges have a vocational focus here and people can come up via the vocational route, although that is rare now. The main reason for the award was so the Principal has a funny hat and cloak to wear at graduation time. No-one uses the actual title.

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#57

The cynical side of me says that honorary degrees are ways of collecting big-name people so that colleges can claim them as one of their own. Our university boasts the like of Richard Stallman and supreme court justices!

Big-name people like heads of state, like the then PM of my country to which the University of Philadelphia in 2004. gave a honorary degree. The same now sits in jail for corruption, fraud, and war profiteering amongst other charges.

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#58
On my graduation, someone called Mr Jack Jones was being given an honorary doctorate. (I understand he was a trade unionist or something, if I may be as dismissive as I possibly can.)

I wanted to walk out when they got to his bit of the ceremony but general cowardliness took over - they might have revoked my degree if I had made a scene!

When he was presented for the applause I did my best to remain seated with my arms folded and a look of disapproval. I observed that over on the other side of the room where the parents were seated, he was getting a standing ovation, while my side of the room could be best described as "polite". No-one (as far I could see) was standing.

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#59
post #53

Awarding an honorary degree is analogous to liking a status update on Facebook.

Not always, it can also be a very overtly political act. Consider playwright Tony Kushner's honorary degree from a CUNY college, among many others.

So can liking an overtly political facebook post.

(Ineffectual potentially but still political.)

Re: Why Do Colleges Give Honorary Degrees?

#60

"Supreme Court member Ruth Bader Ginsburg has an honorary degree from every single Ivy League School, with the exception of Cornell, which doesn’t give them out." ...except for her actual undergrad degree, which is from Cornell. (Hey, when you don't have presidents, you take what you can get. And we'll take RBG over several presidents.)

An earned undergraduate degree is not an 'honorary degree'.

No, but it's a "degree", and she has that university covered too, degree-wise, which is what he means.
Post reply on HN