Live data from Hacker News

Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#21
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reddit still borks during peak hour, after all this years. But not as often as it used to. There was a huge discussion about reddit not implementing better moderation/spamming/vote-rigging and site wide feature tools that has been promised for years. Basically reddit has been bit stagnant feature wise for some time now. Lot were promise with lotsa new hires but nothing much to show for it. With spez being back, hopef…

I mostly read Reddit while not logged in, so I've never seen any latency. I guess it's mostly because of authentication/personalized content stuff, which should be easy to fix, by doing less of them or lazy loading.

I'm always logged in into reddit, but have no personalizations (like favorite subreddit, etc). I know that doesn't really guarantee anything, but reddit still borks at peak time for me. I'd assume it's very little compute for my personalization to load.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#22
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe one day they will fix search?

Most people I know just use Google for site search by adding the site name to the query. More sophisticated queries can use site:reddit.com syntax, but usually adding reddit to a query should have the desired effect. If any DuckDuckGo guy around here, is there a command for reddit search, like !rd or something.

The only DuckDuckGo ones I know of (!r, !reddit) use reddit's own search. Not sure if there are any others that don't

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#23

What are the technology challenges is Reddit facing? Clearly not scaling as it's been pretty reliable. New features? What more feature does one need from Reddit? It's pretty good for what it's doing.

The moderation tools are absolutely archaic. Moderating any subreddit of sufficient size requires a small army of bots and third party tools. Basic forum moderation tools like IP banning persistent troublemakers and spammers are still not available.

hello, what challenges in particular? Are you a moderator?

edit: I saw you posted a few challenges :) I don't work for reddit but if you're a moderator Id be interested to PM you about something around that...

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#24

It is clear that Reddit is facing some problems with scalability. I often get server errors during peak hours. But I think that politically-based censorship, which is being enforced by many moderators (with the help of Reddit admins), will kill this service sooner than scalability problems. Users will simply left Reddit when they will become censored. Many users I knew already did that. Moreover, moderators of many s…

What are you referring to you when you talk about politically-based censorship? I was increasingly turned off by the growing racism, misogyny, and hate that I saw daily on Reddit, and am quite happy to see many of the most disgusting subreddits finally done away with. I suspect that for every free-speech absolutist worried about Reddit refusing to sanction such vitriol there are many more that will be happy to find a more inclusive, welcoming Reddit. I know I'm one of the latter.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#25
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reddit still borks during peak hour, after all this years. But not as often as it used to. There was a huge discussion about reddit not implementing better moderation/spamming/vote-rigging and site wide feature tools that has been promised for years. Basically reddit has been bit stagnant feature wise for some time now. Lot were promise with lotsa new hires but nothing much to show for it. With spez being back, hopef…

I mostly read Reddit while not logged in, so I've never seen any latency. I guess it's mostly because of authentication/personalized content stuff, which should be easy to fix, by doing less of them or lazy loading.

Maybe they serve more cached content to not logged users while being more careful about serving up-to-date one to the logged ones? It's just a wild guess I have no idea how it works.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#26

It is clear that Reddit is facing some problems with scalability. I often get server errors during peak hours. But I think that politically-based censorship, which is being enforced by many moderators (with the help of Reddit admins), will kill this service sooner than scalability problems. Users will simply left Reddit when they will become censored. Many users I knew already did that. Moreover, moderators of many s…

There is no need to bring reddit intra-site politics here. I doubt readers could care less about SJW vs anti-SJW factions on another site. Furthermore, the actions of certain moderators have nothing to do with this staffing announcement, so you are doubly off-topic. It would make me happy at least if we could contain reddit politics to reddit itself.

Readers already pointed out here lack of IP banning tools as one of the technical challenges Reddit is facing. I wanted to bring up the context of such demands.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#27
post #24

It is clear that Reddit is facing some problems with scalability. I often get server errors during peak hours. But I think that politically-based censorship, which is being enforced by many moderators (with the help of Reddit admins), will kill this service sooner than scalability problems. Users will simply left Reddit when they will become censored. Many users I knew already did that. Moreover, moderators of many s…

What are you referring to you when you talk about politically-based censorship? I was increasingly turned off by the growing racism, misogyny, and hate that I saw daily on Reddit, and am quite happy to see many of the most disgusting subreddits finally done away with. I suspect that for every free-speech absolutist worried about Reddit refusing to sanction such vitriol there are many more that will be happy to find a…

Advocating against censorship and arguing against banning subreddits is not equivalent to supporting those subreddits. Basic, undergraduate-level logic.

The fact is that there are plenty of hateful subreddits explicitly supported by admins and mods (e.g., SRS) but the hate is pointed in the 'right' direction (i.e., +SJW).

And the point of the above is that there is clearly bias shaping the site's content from the very top. This stands in direct contradiction to the founders statements years ago about creating a "bastion of free speech".

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The moderation tools are absolutely archaic. Moderating any subreddit of sufficient size requires a small army of bots and third party tools. Basic forum moderation tools like IP banning persistent troublemakers and spammers are still not available.

hello, what challenges in particular? Are you a moderator? edit: I saw you posted a few challenges :) I don't work for reddit but if you're a moderator Id be interested to PM you about something around that...

I am a moderator of several large (300k plus) subreddits. Same username here as there, or also @gmail.com. I'm happy to chat about the challenges of moderating these large communities.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mostly read Reddit while not logged in, so I've never seen any latency. I guess it's mostly because of authentication/personalized content stuff, which should be easy to fix, by doing less of them or lazy loading.

Maybe they serve more cached content to not logged users while being more careful about serving up-to-date one to the logged ones? It's just a wild guess I have no idea how it works.

Reddit definitely makes use of it's CDN and caching for logged out users. Since they make up the significant proportion (exact statistics escape me) of visitors, it's not surprising that's where their effort has been directed.

In contrast, every page load by a logged-in user requires unique database queries for things like vote status on submissions and comments.

Re: Reddit Names Marty Weiner, Early Engineer at Pinterest, Its First CTO

#30

What is a "founding engineer"? It must not mean founder, since then one would just say "founder". It's clearly not Director of Engineering, CTO, or VP o E. I had just assumed this was new phrasing used by recruiters and business people trying to get early engineer hires that they don't want to give a real title to (because if/when the company grows they'll bring in adults to run things and get those titles.) Note, se…

Basically "Engineer hire #1" (or similar) that was on board super early but wasn't part of the founding team when the team itself was formed. I am guessing the distinction is to delineate the fact that the engineer did not join 1+ year from company founding, which is often the case for Engineer #1.

So basically founder minus the shares?
Post reply on HN