Live data from Hacker News

Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

washingtonpost.com

61–68 of 68 posts

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#61
post #52
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

usually eat at noon or after, then dinner. I don't snack, never eat sugar. I think it's because of the portions I eat :| alcohol might be for something as well.

It could be due to hormone imbalance, have you checked your thyroid and testosterone levels?

Not a bad idea.

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#63

At the end of the day it will always be calories in vs. calories out. My personal experience is that I try to only eat 1 meal per day. Intermittent fasting is nothing new, and when I combine it with a low carb diet, it is extremely effective for me. I went from ~300 down to 225 in a matter of 4-5 months. As long as I am busy, I hardly notice any hunger during the day now that I am used to the schedule and the 1 meal…

> At the end of the day it will always be calories in vs. calories out. This is based on the assumption that all calories are digested and metabolized. Calorie is simply a unit of energy. There are calories in paper, charcoal and wood, so taking that to the extreme would mean that one would gain the same amount of weight consuming a bunch of shredded paper as consuming, let's say, a donut, yet digestion does not work…

At that point I would imagine it's the same concept as net carbs. Obviously not all food/matter is digestible. I do think it's still safe to say calories in/calories out however since most of us aren't entering shredded paper, charcoal and wood into MFP logs.

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> At the end of the day it will always be calories in vs. calories out. This is based on the assumption that all calories are digested and metabolized. Calorie is simply a unit of energy. There are calories in paper, charcoal and wood, so taking that to the extreme would mean that one would gain the same amount of weight consuming a bunch of shredded paper as consuming, let's say, a donut, yet digestion does not work…

At that point I would imagine it's the same concept as net carbs. Obviously not all food/matter is digestible. I do think it's still safe to say calories in/calories out however since most of us aren't entering shredded paper, charcoal and wood into MFP logs.

While you can control the input, the output gets harder - one cannot just simply double/triple their defecation rate, and exercise tends to work out an appetite.

http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/11/12/exercising-but-gain...

Output is governed by hormones, and the only reliable hack for now seems to be significantly lowering insulin by switching to ketogenic diet (or a variation thereof, /r/zerocarb, /r/keto, Atkins, Dukan). I'd recommend this book https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Calories,_Bad_Calories with understanding that a lot of nutrition and diet science is in very premature stage because of World War 2 and lack of funding thereafter.

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> At the end of the day it will always be calories in vs. calories out. This is based on the assumption that all calories are digested and metabolized. Calorie is simply a unit of energy. There are calories in paper, charcoal and wood, so taking that to the extreme would mean that one would gain the same amount of weight consuming a bunch of shredded paper as consuming, let's say, a donut, yet digestion does not work…

At that point I would imagine it's the same concept as net carbs. Obviously not all food/matter is digestible. I do think it's still safe to say calories in/calories out however since most of us aren't entering shredded paper, charcoal and wood into MFP logs.

I once read that different kinds of food deliver calories in forms with different degrees of absorb-ability.

Source: http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/why-most-food-...

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#66

Not eating makes you lose weight. Doesn't matter when you eat, eating less, and eating better food (fresh, non-processed. If it doesn't run, grow on a tree/plant, or swim, don't eat it) will make you lose weight.

> Not eating makes you lose weight. Exception being the cases when it doesn't http://bradpilon.com/weight-loss/fasting-for-weight-loss/can...

What he described in this article was not just fasting, but a sequence of fasting and non-fasting days. Of course, if you fast for a day, and the next day eat all the calories back and more, you will gain.

Re: Skipping breakfast might help you lose weight

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1 bottle of beer is usually between 100 and 300 carrots, depending on what type of beer and how much alcohol is in it. Alcohol is a significant source of calories. Have you tried not drinking for a few months? The rule of thumb I've heard is that 1 pound of weight can be lost with a 3500 calorie deficit. If you drink between 10 and 30 beets a week, cutting beer could cause you to start losing weight.

carrots? beets? Thanks for the laughs, autocorrect.

I'm not going to touch the parent in case anyone else needs a laugh.
Post reply on HN