Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause

github.com

1–10 of 136 posts

Re: GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause

#3
Looking through some of the issues on that repo, the amount of bad faith people have in the very idea of a code of conduct is astonishing. Not to mention the sheer ignorance of issues affecting minorities within the tech community (seriously, Jon Stewart could have had a weeks worth of material).

Sure, the wording of the code of conduct wasn't perfect, but it'd be much nicer if people wanted to see it improved in good faith. There's a lot of ugly things that happen in open source projects, which aren't rosy as some may assume, and the idea that making more people feel welcomed and safe in communities like GitHub can't take precedent over the possibility that a few current contributors will find themselves outside the rules on a regular basis is very worrying.

Re: GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause

#6

> to protect people who are typically the target of harassment in open source So if you are subjected to an unusual type of harassment, you're on your own?

I guess the idea is, to prevent (or at least discourage) the usual types of harassment up-front, and deal with the more unusual, rare forms on-the-fly as they appear.

Re: GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause

#8
post #5

I fail to see how this has anything to do with GitHub, except using GitHub as a hosting platform. Can somebody please change the title?

Github recently adopted this Code of Conduct for all of their own-brand projects, and they were encouraging other open source projects to adopt it as well: https://github.com/blog/2039-adopting-the-open-code-of-condu...

Re: GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause

#9

Looking through some of the issues on that repo, the amount of bad faith people have in the very idea of a code of conduct is astonishing. Not to mention the sheer ignorance of issues affecting minorities within the tech community (seriously, Jon Stewart could have had a weeks worth of material). Sure, the wording of the code of conduct wasn't perfect, but it'd be much nicer if people wanted to see it improved in goo…

It seems like a lot of people are just upset because they feel the CoC discriminates against them.

You are harassed and have privileges ? I don't care, being harassed is still not fine whether you have privileges or not.

Seems to sum up what most people are complaining about.

Post reply on HN