Live data from Hacker News

The gimp.org domain has expired

gimp.org

41–50 of 96 posts

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#41
post #38

We should stop using the domain name system to name web pages and email addresses. It is too vulnerable to legal attacks, extralegal attacks, and simple human error. There are a bunch of decentralized possibilities out there: IPFS, Tahoe-LAFS, MaidSafe, and so on. None of them are ready yet, except (for some purposes) FreeNet and Tor Onion Services, and it's going to be a lot of work to get them to work, and probably…

Is there a good alternative idea?

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#42
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or maybe you are using the old IP from your DNS cache?

I don't understand registrars that don't alert you to the fact that it is going to expire. I have that registrar that everyone loves to hate and they are damn good at reminding me when to renew and not annoying me in between such times. (as in, I have godaddy)

I'm pretty sure every registrar does this. It is in their interest: they remind you to pay so they get your money instead of some other registra getting a poacher's money.

A key problem is people not seeing the reminders. Perhaps they get lost in a sea of spam. Perhaps they get accidently calssifed as spem themselves. Perhaps the contact information for the domain isn't kept up-to-date and the reminders end up in an email account that is no longer monitored.

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#43
post #38

We should stop using the domain name system to name web pages and email addresses. It is too vulnerable to legal attacks, extralegal attacks, and simple human error. There are a bunch of decentralized possibilities out there: IPFS, Tahoe-LAFS, MaidSafe, and so on. None of them are ready yet, except (for some purposes) FreeNet and Tor Onion Services, and it's going to be a lot of work to get them to work, and probably…

Care to propose and develop an alternative?

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#44
post #38

We should stop using the domain name system to name web pages and email addresses. It is too vulnerable to legal attacks, extralegal attacks, and simple human error. There are a bunch of decentralized possibilities out there: IPFS, Tahoe-LAFS, MaidSafe, and so on. None of them are ready yet, except (for some purposes) FreeNet and Tor Onion Services, and it's going to be a lot of work to get them to work, and probably…

Excellent plan.

Now we only need to worry about the small matters designing an alternative system that acheives what the domain name system does without those draw-backs, and convincing people to use the new system...

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#45

https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/expired-2013-05-03-en Domains have a renewal grace period. Since it expired recently, they'll be fine.

so all I have to do in order for my comment to be on top is to reply to the most voted comment ? :)

(please do not reply, so my comment will stay on top :) )

edit 1: after few quick downvotes, i am still here, on top :)

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#46
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shouldn't the registrar do that? Namecheap sends me multiple emails when any of my domains is about to expire, it's just common business sense.

1&1 and gandi both offer automatic renewal. In fact I don't think I would use a registrar that didn't offer that. More likely what happened was that the guy who was incharge disappeared and/or his credit card number changed. And when the registrar tried to renew - it couldn't and I'm sure sent tons of emails of "HEY YOU NEED TO FIX THIS". Something similar almost happened to CentOS.

I've been with Gandi for years, absolutely love them

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#48
post #38

We should stop using the domain name system to name web pages and email addresses. It is too vulnerable to legal attacks, extralegal attacks, and simple human error. There are a bunch of decentralized possibilities out there: IPFS, Tahoe-LAFS, MaidSafe, and so on. None of them are ready yet, except (for some purposes) FreeNet and Tor Onion Services, and it's going to be a lot of work to get them to work, and probably…

I like your idea, contact me at a930e4bc4ff969fe52437f14b50535ae908683af and we'll discuss next steps :)

Re: The gimp.org domain has expired

#49

This is exactly why we created a domain name/ssl reminder tool: http://www.expirify.com . A really easy mistake to make and very costly, I hope they get it back

Easy? Really? I get that you are offering a service, but I can guarantee that if there were something as fundamentally and existentially important as securing my domain name, it would not be an easy thing to forget to do. I can't even begin comprehending how one forgets to do such a thing.
Post reply on HN