Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

graz.io

181–190 of 259 posts

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#181

This is the keyboard I’ve been hoping Apple would make for years! I’ve currently got a UHK 60 but would probably switch to this if I could buy it. Especially if it had the standard Apple keyboard layout so my fingers don’t need to relearn things like arrow keys and cmd like when I switch between the UHK and MacBook keyboard.

I really just want a wireless 60v2. Been debating trying to make a new PCB that uses a nice!nano.

I’m sure the devils in the details.

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#182
post #102

The grid layout makes this look so futuristic (and anime [1]). It looks very cool, though I wonder how long it'd take to get used to one, having only ever typed on staggered layouts. [1] https://gifer.com/es/BFCV

I went from only using my MacBook's builtin keyboard to using a Lily58 split keyboard and it took probably about 2 weeks to fully adjust. I started out at around 100-110 wpm on the standard keyboard. On the first day of the split I was doing about 20-30 wpm, after a week I was up to 60 wpm, and then 80wpm after 2 weeks. Kept improving more slowly after that. I did switch cold turkey, i.e. using it 100% of the time including at work.

Now I'm about a year and a half later and am up to 140wpm. I think the biggest problem for me on the standard keyboard is the bottom row index fingers and pinkies, the "natural" motion of my fingers lands right in between the two keys on those fingers so I used to make a lot of mistakes there, especially when typing fast.

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have the voyager and I'm really very happy with it. No wrist pain when I'm typing a lot. https://imgur.com/pklEZSh Ambients Silent Choc Switches (20g Linear), keycaps from worklouder (Pure)

Gorgeous! How do the worklouder pures compare to the stock keycaps?

I wasn't sure how I would like the keycaps when I ordered it. Hard to describe but they feel better than the stock keycaps (with the silent switches) and sound a little better when I strike the plastic keycaps. The stock keycaps have a slight hollow sound (if I recall correctly).

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#185
post #74

For next iteration, consider integrating trackpads? Moving to the mouse and back is pain enough that people go all-in on keyboard-only interfaces. I velcroed a trackpad to the middle of a Kinesis Advantage. Now I use either hand for the mouse, and even stretch a finger or thumb to the pad without leaving the keys. The movement is little different from using the keyboard. But for split keyboard, you'd need one trackpa…

I want a trackpads integrated into the keys. Under the J key a trackpad with low sensitifity, and under the K key a trackpad with high sensitivity.

Brilliant! Use modifier keys with your left hand for either key entry or mouse click?

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#186
post #146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pain indeed. I tried an ortho layout a few weeks ago on a split Corne and developed really bad wrist pain. No idea why, but it went away after reverting to a stagger and giving that hand a break

I’m personally not convinced by the theory of ortho. It seems to stem from the idea that stagger is a hangover from the typewriter, in which it was required to make room for the mechanics, and that if we didn’t need to make them like that, we wouldn’t have. Hence the keys should be lined up so your fingers just move up and down. However I think this has 2 problems. 1) Most ortho keyboards have 5 columns for 4 fingers…

> the theory of ortho

What theory of ortho? It's merely a rejection of stagger. Stagger represents our unwillingness to try new things even if the old thing makes no sense whatsoever.

OK, attitude aside now: for me it's partly about the ability to find keys by feel. With stagger you can learn touch typing one row above the home row and one row below the home row, no problem. But when you start trying to learn touch typing for the number row the difficulty jumps up significantly, because the nonsensical stagger makes it difficult to feel your way up the column.

So the benefits of ortho, according to me:

- It's easier to touch type once you eliminate the stagger, especially when deviating more than one row.

- Being better able to feel your way around helps with gaming, as does removing the stagger from WASD.

- Being straightened out allows you to map a numpad over the keys, to be invoked with a function key. I tried this with stagger and it was awful.

- I just dig the way it looks. It's like a lazy cartoon drawing of a keyboard.

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#187
post #152

This is the keyboard I’ve been hoping Apple would make for years! I’ve currently got a UHK 60 but would probably switch to this if I could buy it. Especially if it had the standard Apple keyboard layout so my fingers don’t need to relearn things like arrow keys and cmd like when I switch between the UHK and MacBook keyboard.

Me too. Low-profile is nicer to joints in the long run, and also makes me type faster due to low-travel switches. Bonus points if it has a little bit of negative tilt. In this regard, I found Microsoft Sculpt really good because it ticked all ergonomic boxes but it didn't require relearning. However, quality was a bit subpar, it didn't offer a wired option, and it has been discontinued. The entire lineup was actually…

I have had 3 of which 1 has bricked itself.

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#188
This is so funny, I dived into the custom keyboard rabbit hole just 3 weeks ago. Never thought this would be so intriguing and time consuming.

Did you consider Mill-Max Sockets?

My personal favorite are 80% TKL ISO low profile keyboards, which is quite uncommon and I've not found much except the

  Keychron K1 Max 
having this layout. Unfortunately, the integrated Gateron brown/red/... low profile switches are not my thing - my favorite ones would be Lofree Kailh Ghost, but these don't fit the keyboard, although it is hot swappable because low profile switches are non standard (at least 2 different layouts I know of).

So I also thought about a custom solution. I found pretty impressive open source firmware and pcbs [1], but I noticed that I just didn't have the time to do all this. Since keyboards are so an individual device, manufacturing bigger batches is risky and manufacturing smaller batches is expensive... so pretty much no choice than waiting for someone having the same dream as I have or do it myself after shoving free enough time.

1: https://github.com/4pplet/waffling80/issues/1

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#189
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry for uninvited advice, but you really shouldn't be using the keys in the corners for common actions (so common that you have a need to take the load off you pinkies). Utilise the CapsLock [1, 2]. (This key is so misbalanced in terms of prime key estate to utility ratio!) Better yet, try using home row modifiers [3]. [1]: https://wiki.c2.com/?RemapCapsLock [2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/vim/comments/1442ads/mappin…

Mostly the offenders are enter and -=[];'./_+{}:">?. My solution was to move \)}>][ https://configure.zsa.io/planck-ez/layouts/RgRVl/latest/1 So I guess that means that the position formerly occupied by caps lock is now... 'a'? I haven't bothered to configure a caps lock. Haven't needed it. Bonus, this is all handled in the keyboard firmware so I don't have to bother reconfiguring the OS. I just plug in the keyboard…

TBF, I strayed quite far from “normal” keyboard as well [1]: I use a 36 key split (15+3 for each hand); Dvorak layout; all special symbols are on L2; return, escape, tab, and space are on the thumb clusters (along with backspace and language switcher); modifiers are on the home row. All this ensures no finger ever has to travel more than one key away from its resting position. I’m quite happy with this setup and am working on a thinner and more polished version of my keyboard. To each their own, I guess.

[1]: Writing the GP comment I was cautious not to be that rando who goes “you’re doing it all wrong! you gotta reconfigure your whole system and your brain!” to a stranger, so I limited myself to the, IMHO, bare minimum advice. ;)

Re: Show HN: Bayleaf – Building a low-profile wireless split keyboard

#190
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mostly the offenders are enter and -=[];'./_+{}:">?. My solution was to move \)}>][ https://configure.zsa.io/planck-ez/layouts/RgRVl/latest/1 So I guess that means that the position formerly occupied by caps lock is now... 'a'? I haven't bothered to configure a caps lock. Haven't needed it. Bonus, this is all handled in the keyboard firmware so I don't have to bother reconfiguring the OS. I just plug in the keyboard…

TBF, I strayed quite far from “normal” keyboard as well [1]: I use a 36 key split (15+3 for each hand); Dvorak layout; all special symbols are on L2; return, escape, tab, and space are on the thumb clusters (along with backspace and language switcher); modifiers are on the home row. All this ensures no finger ever has to travel more than one key away from its resting position. I’m quite happy with this setup and am w…

I like the look of those minimal split setups. I'm currently using a planck half the time and an ergodox the other half. But because my brain has moved into the planck, more than 50% of the keys on the ergodox are just gathering dust.

My next step on this path, if I ever take it, probably resembles your setup. If/when I take it, I'll explore the modifiers on home row approach, it does sound nice :)

Post reply on HN