Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution

giveinternet.org

121–124 of 124 posts

Re: Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution

#121
post #116
post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure there are more important things to solve for so many families, but In the modern world, we can skip on gradually solving basic needs. We can and should leapfrog. Furthermore, we believe that internet access and access to information can play a catalyst role in solving those problems. Today we take the internet for granted, but it's luxury for so many people. It is a commodity like water and electricity. One thin…

Okay, what is the first thing the poor families should be doing after getting the said internet connection? Is the answer - job opportunities, free education, survival skills? The truth is that the internet does provide these, but how many of them actually use it?

What we can say from our experience of working with poor students, is that they are no different from those kids around us. Contrary to popular belief, the underprivileged accept advanced technology as readily as we do.

Young people adopt technology easily and use it the same way their peers in wealthy countries and sometimes even more consciously because their problems are much different from the first world ones. They use it to serve their basic needs, but also it becomes a window to the world and opportunities for them - a chance. Internet helps them discover their interests and passions, trying things out and learn about new professions they've never heard about.

Anyway, it is better to be connected in today's world, than not. Why? because of the same reasons why none of us here on HN would give up their connection.

Re: Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution

#122
post #35

My wife started a school/community center is Africa and we are one of the only places in town with computers and internet you can use for free. It was a rare occasion indeed that anyone wanted to do anything except watch youtube videos. Now that we banned youtube, people honestly aren't really that interested. I'm not saying internet is bad or whatever, it's just that it's not going to change people's lives without a…

> Now that we banned youtube, people honestly aren't really that interested.

I recently saw some Sci-Fi shorts made by some Nigerian kids using some really interesting hacks to work around their economic and resource constraints. They were primarily inspired by watching other shorts, and learnt how to do video-editing etc from Youtube videos. I think banning anything that you consider "wasteful" isn't productive.

> Educating people so they have questions to ask, or things to produce, or knowledge to acquire.

Maybe you didn't mean to but this sounds rather patronising. Also, they were acquiring knowledge, just not knowledge that you wanted them to acquire.

Re: Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution

#123
post #35

My wife started a school/community center is Africa and we are one of the only places in town with computers and internet you can use for free. It was a rare occasion indeed that anyone wanted to do anything except watch youtube videos. Now that we banned youtube, people honestly aren't really that interested. I'm not saying internet is bad or whatever, it's just that it's not going to change people's lives without a…

> Now that we banned youtube That's a pity. YouTube is a treasure of awesome educational videos, better than any school can be. If only I had YouTube when I was a schoolboy... Cool people explain math (and other subjects) I could never understand but grok instantly this way. I can also hardly imagine a better media spreading cultural progress. It also promotes artistic expression, incl in poor people - have you seen…

> if somebody watches nothing but stupid/weird stuff

the issue with that, is what counts as stupid/weird? Is watching vlogs stupid/weird? Is watching people like Logan Paul, weird or stupid? One could argue that you could actually learn alot from people like Logan Paul, about what to do and what not to do.

Also, people can learn things from the unlikeliest of sources.

Re: Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution

#124
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Stundents" -> "Students"

Amazing Google still has 6,160,000,000 hits for the prior. IMHO, it is a new word due to large typos.

Google's search results are pretty meaningless these days due to changes in presentation of results and inference of intent
Post reply on HN