Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 117 posts

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#31
post #26

I don't know how the latest stuff from OpenAI will impract the career of average programmers. But regarding your last question: > how would you try to AI-proof your career? Learn to program from first principles.

Yeah, it is likely that AI can learn to glue code from stack overflow pretty soon. Harder programming that requires you to do a bit of thinking seems more future proof, these models aren't good at thinking at all instead they just pattern match and glue in previous solutions.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#33

My immediate guess is that these kinds of tools will greatly enlarge the productivity gap between junior and senior developers. Senior devs will be able (they already are) to generate code, at first boilerplate and gradually more complex code, and effectively work as planners and passive reviewers, in a similar way to how some companies just hire legions of juniors with some architects/seniors guiding and reviewing t…

That's an interesting take. The ChatGPT seems to do very well at doing what it's told, but it needs very explicit requirements and supervision to discover missing requirements. It's a junior developer, basically.

That could put junior developers out of a job just like glass terminals put many data entry and server room operators out of jobs.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#35
That's too early to know for sure but for now I'm not that impressed yet. Yes sure those can be great tools for helping developers but replacing jobs? Maybe the most boring jobs possible could be automated with that and I'm not even sure.

Who will review and maintain the code produced apart from a developer anyways?

If you think about it it's much less revolutionary in terms of reducing coding jobs than WordPress.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#37
The current crop of generative AI all seems like it could produce useful tools for various practitioners, programmers included, I don't yet see evidence for replacing jobs. But it's hard to extrapolate.

That said the best way to anything-proof this career that's so lucrative is to be frugal and set yourself up to retire early.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#39

Funnily enough I was just asking chatGPT what it thought about it, so here it goes: >It is unlikely that AI will completely replace programmers. While AI and machine learning technology has advanced significantly in recent years, there are still many tasks that require human creativity and intuition, such as coming up with new ideas, solving complex problems, and making decisions that involve subjective judgement. Ad…

Which is about the same what would Skynet say :)
Post reply on HN