Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

news.ycombinator.com

161–170 of 208 posts

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#161
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Visit his site. "Moltbook is the most interesting place on the internet right now" It's immediately obvious it's bullshit.

Gonna have to disagree with you there chief. I've followed SimonW for quite some time and bullshit/grifting is just NOT something he does. On the contrary, I've learned a great deal from him and appreciate his contributions.

There are some things that you should not admit publicly lol.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"it's nothing new and it's a lot of scams and garbage, but it's just bigger than before, but I still think there will be something transformative there eventually" Seems like a Rorschach test. If you think this sort of thing is gonna change the world in a good way: here's evidence of it getting to scale. If you think it's gonna be scams, garbage, and destruction: here's evidence of that.

Agents are many things but they are definitely not "scams" - if you think this you've probably stubbornly avoided using Claude Code etc.

What the fuck are you talking about man. What are you ever saying. You are the mark.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Visit his site. "Moltbook is the most interesting place on the internet right now" It's immediately obvious it's bullshit.

I completely and utterly disagree. Simon is no gifter. Intellectually lazy snobs think that any time someone has genuine delight and excitement about something that they’re “grifting.” Also, for anyone who is trying (regardless of whether they are succeeding) the to make money—that isn’t synonymous with “grifting.” God, some of you need a better relationship with a dictionary. Plus, it seems some of y’all love to hat…

[flagged]

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Visit his site. "Moltbook is the most interesting place on the internet right now" It's immediately obvious it's bullshit.

I completely and utterly disagree. Simon is no gifter. Intellectually lazy snobs think that any time someone has genuine delight and excitement about something that they’re “grifting.” Also, for anyone who is trying (regardless of whether they are succeeding) the to make money—that isn’t synonymous with “grifting.” God, some of you need a better relationship with a dictionary. Plus, it seems some of y’all love to hat…

I really hope you're making a lot of money out of this, because if not, this comment just comes across as sad.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#165

I've been messing with it the past couple days. I put it in a VM, on an untrusted subnet I keep around for agentic stuff. I see promise, but I'm not especially impressed right now. 1) Installation on a clean Ubuntu 24.04 system was messy. I eventually had codex do it for me. 2) It has a bunch of skills that come packaged with it. The ones I've tried do not work all that well. 3) It murdered my codex quota trying to c…

I have set it up in a docker container that only has two host volumes mounted with the Obsidian vaults where I keep notes for two TTRPG campaigns, so a very low-stakes situation. I have set it up with a Discord bot so my players can chat about campaign and rules stuff (I already had player-facing notes for every session in the Obsidian vault in chronological order, plus a bunch of Markdown files with rules).

If the agent goes rogue and nukes my Obsidian vaults I have them backed up to Github private repos anyway which the agent cannot touch because I am not crazy to give it my SSH credentials.

I initially tried using Kimi-2.5 through OpenRouter and had the same experience you had with pretty bad tool use, not sure if this is a provider issue since it is a pretty new model. I switched to Gemini 3 through the Google AI Pro account I have for personal use and it was a lot smoother after that.

I have some experience with coding agents using Cursor for work and Antigravity for personal stuff, and the OpenClaw harness definitely seems worse, but for my low-stakes use-case I managed to paper it over with some edits to the AGENTS.md file.

But even in this very crude state it was already interesting to see one of my players giving the agent some info about his character, including an avatar image, and have the agent create a folder in my Obsidian vault to store this and update its memory file to be able to remember it for future interactions.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#166

Yes, I’m running it with a minimal set of plugins. When I’m driving or out I can ask Siri to send a iMessage to Clawdbot something like “Can you find out if anything is playing at the local concert venue, and figure in how much 2 tickets would cost”, and a few minutes later it will give me a few options. It even surprised me and researched the different seats and recommended a cheaper one or free activities as an alt…

How are you running Kimi locally?

I have an AMD Epyc machine with 512GB of RAM and a humble NVIDIA 3090. You will have to run a quantized version but you can get a couple tokens per second out of it since these models are optimized to split across the GPU/RAM and it's about as good as Claude was 12 months ago.

Full disclosure, I use OpenRouter and pay for models most of the time since it's more practical than 5-10 tokens per second, but the option to run it "If I had to, worst case" is good enough for me. We're also in a rapidly developing technology space and the models are getting smaller and better by the day, ever year the smaller models get better

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#167
Real user here, 7 days in. Mac Mini M4 from Costco (~$640), running Opus 4.5 via Claude Max. Using it as an autonomous employee for two actual businesses (SaaS + AV rentals in Orange County).

What actually works:

- Overnight autonomous work is the killer feature. Directive before bed, structured deliverables in the morning. Research reports, competitor analysis, lead lists — genuinely usable, not demos.

- It found and fixed an SMS chatbot that had been broken for 10 months in my CRM. Diagnosed a legacy app version issue, upgraded components, rewrote the bot prompt through 6 iterations by analyzing real customer conversations. I never would've gotten to that.

- Connected to 4 new APIs autonomously in one session (CRM, workflow automation via OAuth, admin APIs, embeddings).

- Memory works surprisingly well. Daily markdown logs + semantic search. It references decisions from days ago and builds on previous work.

What doesn't:

- It hallucinated about itself when writing marketing copy. Invented revenue figures and got hardware specs wrong. Everything needs review.

- Browser automation is brittle. Rich text editors, complex UIs — still needs human intervention.

- Too agreeable by default. Had to explicitly program "push back on bad ideas" rules into its personality file.

Revenue generated: $0. Time saved: hard to quantify but the SMS bot fix alone would've taken me a full day I didn't have.

For solo founders willing to invest setup time: worth it. For people who just want a chatbot: massive overkill, use the API directly.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I completely and utterly disagree. Simon is no gifter. Intellectually lazy snobs think that any time someone has genuine delight and excitement about something that they’re “grifting.” Also, for anyone who is trying (regardless of whether they are succeeding) the to make money—that isn’t synonymous with “grifting.” God, some of you need a better relationship with a dictionary. Plus, it seems some of y’all love to hat…

[flagged]

this sounds like a you need to see a therapist kind of problem

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#169
I am actually setting it up and using it in one day. It is basically unusable. Many tools require homebrew. The setup of authentication is complicated. The default Docker setup is broken (github.com/openclaw/openclaw/issues/5559), and the cron job is not working (https://github.com/openclaw/openclaw/issues/2323). I doubt any story in the comment is real.

Re: Ask HN: Any real OpenClaw (Clawd Bot/Molt Bot) users? What's your experience?

#170

run 6 OpenClaw agents as employees. Buddy is my PA and manages the others. Katy handles X/Twitter growth. Jerry scouts jobs. Burry trades crypto. Mike does security. Elon builds and ships. They run 24/7 on a VPS, share intelligence through a shared file, and coordinate in a Telegram group. Elon built and deployed an app overnight without being asked. Burry paper-traded to 77% win rate before going live. The setup too…

> Elon builds and ships. How good are its Nazi salutes?

your brain has been broken
Post reply on HN