Live data from Hacker News

Why is e^(pi i) = -1?

math.toronto.edu

1–10 of 53 posts

Re: Why is e^(pi i) = -1?

#6

So to broadcast my math ignorance to all: Why does cos(pi) + i sin(pi) == -1 ?? Why does i disappear in this? Edit: Thanks to the replies below.

sin(pi)=0

I wouldn't feel ignorant or anything. The article left out that information seemingly on purpose, presumably so that people would try to figure out where the i went.

Re: Why is e^(pi i) = -1?

#7
For those of you interested in a longer look at this, check out "E, the Story of a Number" by Eli Maor.

Yes, I read when I should probably be hacking.

Re: Why is e^(pi i) = -1?

#8

So to broadcast my math ignorance to all: Why does cos(pi) + i sin(pi) == -1 ?? Why does i disappear in this? Edit: Thanks to the replies below.

The formula is:

e^(ix) = cos(x) - i sin(x)

Since sin(π) == 0, i * 0 == 0 so you have cos(π) left which is -1.

So in sum:

e^(i π) = cos(π) - i sin(π) == -1 - 0 == -1

Re: Why is e^(pi i) = -1?

#10

So to broadcast my math ignorance to all: Why does cos(pi) + i sin(pi) == -1 ?? Why does i disappear in this? Edit: Thanks to the replies below.

If you draw a Sine graph, you will see that sin(x) is zero at 0, pi, 2*pi, ...

If you draw a cosine graph you will see that it is -1 at pi. Therefore in the above sum the sine part just falls away.

It is easy to see that the above is true when you recall that cosine(theta) = adjacent side/(hypotenuse). Since pi=180 degrees, adjacent will be -1 hypotenuse 1 and opposite side 0.

Post reply on HN