Live data from Hacker News

KeyBox: A better way to SSH

sshkeybox.com

1–10 of 57 posts

Re: KeyBox: A better way to SSH

#6
Single point of compromise. :(

I wish people would just stop with these things. The appropriate way to be able to manage many users is called LDAP, it's been LDAP for decades and it's unlikely to change.

These days it's super easy to use SSH keys with LDAP, still using the standard openssh-lpk schema but now not requiring any patches to OpenSSH itself, just need to use the AuthorizedKeysCommand and an appropriate helper (which normally ships with distro).

By forgoing the above gateway style thing you now have central key management without a single point of compromise. Revoking a key is as simple as deleting it from LDAP or disabling that users account.

Re: KeyBox: A better way to SSH

#8
post #6

Single point of compromise. :( I wish people would just stop with these things. The appropriate way to be able to manage many users is called LDAP, it's been LDAP for decades and it's unlikely to change. These days it's super easy to use SSH keys with LDAP, still using the standard openssh-lpk schema but now not requiring any patches to OpenSSH itself, just need to use the AuthorizedKeysCommand and an appropriate hel…

"These days it's super easy to use SSH keys with LDAP"

Are there any articles that go in to detail on exactly how to do this?

Re: KeyBox: A better way to SSH

#10
post #6

Single point of compromise. :( I wish people would just stop with these things. The appropriate way to be able to manage many users is called LDAP, it's been LDAP for decades and it's unlikely to change. These days it's super easy to use SSH keys with LDAP, still using the standard openssh-lpk schema but now not requiring any patches to OpenSSH itself, just need to use the AuthorizedKeysCommand and an appropriate hel…

The thing about keybox is that it's nice and fast to get better. For someone that doesn't have an ops team, or even an ops person, it is a neat solution.

Yes you need to be careful with it, I ran it on an internal VM, with only 2 users who had access to the admin console.

I'd love to see something as simple to use as keybox based around LDAP, I've had a google and can't see anything.

Post reply on HN