Live data from Hacker News

Windows 10 Includes a Linux-Style Package Manager Named “OneGet”

howtogeek.com

1–4 of 4 posts

Re: Windows 10 Includes a Linux-Style Package Manager Named “OneGet”

#3
post #2

Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't want a Linux-style package manager? Why can't apps be self-contained downloadable things with all their dependencies contained within, like back in the Apple Macintosh days?

Because doing something like that is not only a space and data duplication problem, but also a security problem where you have to be sure that when a specific program has a critical bug (let's take openssl for instance) all the "self-contained programs" that you have on your machine get updated at the specific version that can save your ass... and that's become a vendor-specific issue, not something that you as a user or admin can solve directly and easily.

Re: Windows 10 Includes a Linux-Style Package Manager Named “OneGet”

#4
post #2

Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't want a Linux-style package manager? Why can't apps be self-contained downloadable things with all their dependencies contained within, like back in the Apple Macintosh days?

Because the package manager is much more comfortable? I use yaourt on my arch, and without him I would be alone