Live data from Hacker News

Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

kevinwilliamdavid.com

1–10 of 20 posts

Re: Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

#3
Whenever someone makes a system to select for the best, someone else will figure out how to game it. Preparation past a certain point might actually do more harm than good.

It's a very comprehensive list, and I don't want to imply it's bad to organize such a list. I was just surprised at how much stuff has been written about "how to impress YC." The goal is to make something people want, not to impress YC.

Thank you for the list though. It's an awesome collection. I just realized how negative I probably sounded, so I wanted to clarify that your time is very much appreciated in organizing this. I was just wondering how much time YC actually spends defending against people who are primarily trying to game YC rather than trying to make a valuable startup. Maybe it's not even an issue.

Re: Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

#5

Do let me know of any other links from YC partners or Alumni that could be useful for startups applying for Y Combinator.

Nice list.

I wrote a blog post about 'Startup Istanbul 2014'. I have a section with quick advises from Michael Siebel to overseas entrepreneurs. It's pretty small list but I think it's a good quick-list of some general guidelines. The post is here[1] in case you wanna take a look.

[1] http://www.convalesco.org/blog/2014/10/05/startup-istanbul-r...

Re: Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

#7
post #5

Do let me know of any other links from YC partners or Alumni that could be useful for startups applying for Y Combinator.

Nice list. I wrote a blog post about 'Startup Istanbul 2014'. I have a section with quick advises from Michael Siebel to overseas entrepreneurs. It's pretty small list but I think it's a good quick-list of some general guidelines. The post is here[1] in case you wanna take a look. [1] http://www.convalesco.org/blog/2014/10/05/startup-istanbul-r...

Thanks ,good read .I have read his advice before

Re: Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

#9

Whenever someone makes a system to select for the best, someone else will figure out how to game it. Preparation past a certain point might actually do more harm than good. It's a very comprehensive list, and I don't want to imply it's bad to organize such a list. I was just surprised at how much stuff has been written about "how to impress YC." The goal is to make something people want, not to impress YC. Thank you…

It's more like a taste of their own medicine.

YC exists largely to con VCs into being attracted to their golden child chosen companies[2], right? YC batches spend most of their time a.) making their product and b.) refining their pitches to trigger VC fad likability signals of "yah this be hyper megagrowth companay!" [Reminder: early funding is based mostly around personality and psychology first ("gut feelings")[1] largely triggered by the people factor, and then only company details second since early companies change so much in the long run. You can train people to give better first impression gut feelings to increase their funding chances easier than giving them billion dollar execution capability.]

The focus around "we can teach you to manipulate the VCs by telling them what they want" also has an amusing effect: VCs are pandered to so tightly now with such high quality pitches, they get annoyed if you haven't been perfecting a 90 second pitch for 3 months straight. [Bitterness disclosure: I've been rejected by the people who funded Clinkle. Stab me in the eye with a rusty spoon already.]

So, it only makes sense the base of manipulation also has a phase of pre-alignment too.

But—all is not lost! When any process becomes too manipulation-focused, you can out maneuver the manipulators by being good+sincere instead of weak+manipulative.

[2]: with the side effect of creating an extensive "network of friends"/mafia/collusion-sphere/[union?] so they can collectively kick the asses of People With Money And Power who treat any of them poorly. (but, this also creates a great "Let our powers combine!" capability of getting new things done quickly or helping others in need who are part of the family.)

[1]: Are you under 24 with a Stanford background and were born a white male human person? Step right up for your free money!

Re: Guide List for Startups Applying to Y Combinator

#10

Whenever someone makes a system to select for the best, someone else will figure out how to game it. Preparation past a certain point might actually do more harm than good. It's a very comprehensive list, and I don't want to imply it's bad to organize such a list. I was just surprised at how much stuff has been written about "how to impress YC." The goal is to make something people want, not to impress YC. Thank you…

I haven't looked at all of it but I noticed that some of the content is from YC itself, or Partners and alums. As such, I imagine it's the kind of advice that YC might want to have widely disseminated. It's not really gaming the system if you're doing what they suggest (build product, talk to users, etc).
Post reply on HN