Live data from Hacker News

Italy's antitrust watchdog is investigating Google

tech.yahoo.com

1–5 of 5 posts

Re: Italy's antitrust watchdog is investigating Google

#3
post #2

yeah, good idea. The Prime Minister here owns 3 tv channels and somehow more or less controls RAI's other 3 national channels, and they investigate Google...

Well, I think we all agree that google agregating your news should be opt-out, and the threats to stop search-engine-indexing site which doesn't allow its news to be on unrelated news-aggregator service is ridiculous.

So that ridiculousness is worth investigation, sure.

On other hand, I don't see why newspapers would object aggregating their articles into google news. Google news is all about links to the newspaper sites; it's a source of clicks, not a way to steal content.

Re: Italy's antitrust watchdog is investigating Google

#4
post #3
post #2

yeah, good idea. The Prime Minister here owns 3 tv channels and somehow more or less controls RAI's other 3 national channels, and they investigate Google...

Well, I think we all agree that google agregating your news should be opt-out, and the threats to stop search-engine-indexing site which doesn't allow its news to be on unrelated news-aggregator service is ridiculous. So that ridiculousness is worth investigation, sure. On other hand, I don't see why newspapers would object aggregating their articles into google news. Google news is all about links to the newspaper s…

I'm also curious about why companies might want to opt out of the news aggregator.

Although I'm wondering why companies even have a say in it. Isn't the aggregation involved fair use? If I start my own news aggregator do I have to ask publishing companies permission? I feel like I should be able to just aggregate them whether they like it or not.

Re: Italy's antitrust watchdog is investigating Google

#5
post #3
post #2

yeah, good idea. The Prime Minister here owns 3 tv channels and somehow more or less controls RAI's other 3 national channels, and they investigate Google...

Well, I think we all agree that google agregating your news should be opt-out, and the threats to stop search-engine-indexing site which doesn't allow its news to be on unrelated news-aggregator service is ridiculous. So that ridiculousness is worth investigation, sure. On other hand, I don't see why newspapers would object aggregating their articles into google news. Google news is all about links to the newspaper s…

can't they just setup robots.txt?