Live data from Hacker News

Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

nytimes.com

1–10 of 144 posts

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#2
> It also offers a portrait of Silicon Valley engineers that differs sharply from their current caricature as well-paid villains who are driving up the price of real estate in San Francisco and making the city unbearable for others.

What? "unbearable"? That seems a little out of place. Would most NYTimes readers have any idea what he's talking about?

From the author's recent articles list:

--

In little more than a decade, Google has become essential and omnipresent. Now the question is whether people will start to resent and oppose it.

--

As entrepreneurs invade regulated industries and evade traditional watchdogs, the question of who is responsible when something goes wrong looms large.

--

Airbnb likes to say that it gives more people the money they need to pay their bills. But new research suggests that as the sharing industry spreads, more people are going to need that money, because they’ll be unemployed.

--

Uber and a Child's Death

--

Hard-hit by recession, many in Europe have questioned whether jobs at Amazon’s warehouses there are good for the economy or dehumanizing.

--

seems to exclusively write negative stories about bay area tech

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#3

> It also offers a portrait of Silicon Valley engineers that differs sharply from their current caricature as well-paid villains who are driving up the price of real estate in San Francisco and making the city unbearable for others. What? "unbearable"? That seems a little out of place. Would most NYTimes readers have any idea what he's talking about? From the author's recent articles list: -- In little more than a de…

Wow, did Eric Schmidt run over his dog or something? Guy's got a serious bias!

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#4
Can Software Engineers in California that weren't working at one of these companies get in on this class action? I mean even if you weren't at one of those companies its easy to see how suppressing wages at the largest companies would suppress wages for the entire industry.

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#5
What can the villains in this drama use as power to force their illegal price fixing on reluctant companies?

Just what you'd expect.

"Mr. Jobs proposed a no-poaching deal to Edward T. Colligan, Palm’s chief executive. Mr. Colligan responded that such a deal would be unfair to employees as well as “likely illegal.” Mr. Jobs then threatened to unleash Apple’s patent lawyers on Palm."

Yep. It's our badly broken patent system yet again.

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#7
post #3

> It also offers a portrait of Silicon Valley engineers that differs sharply from their current caricature as well-paid villains who are driving up the price of real estate in San Francisco and making the city unbearable for others. What? "unbearable"? That seems a little out of place. Would most NYTimes readers have any idea what he's talking about? From the author's recent articles list: -- In little more than a de…

Wow, did Eric Schmidt run over his dog or something? Guy's got a serious bias!

No. It has worked out well for his career.

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/s...

"In 2013, Mr. Streitfeld was part of the team awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Explanatory Reporting “for its penetrating look into business practices by Apple and other technology companies that illustrates the darker side of a changing global economy for workers and consumers."

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#8
I have personally witnessed the frustrating side of this "no poaching" pact. A close friend was tired of the "Manager Arrogance" at one of these colluding companies.

He quietly put out the word,pretty quickly got approached by a hiring manager at another company - things were going swimmingly.

Then the Hiring manager put in the Req to HR - a V.P. called him personally and but confirmed this "no poaching" B.S. The wage hike would have been considerable for my friend (you can guess the two companies - Arrogant vs Top Payer) & he was pretty upset to learn that the real reason was Jobs being a Huge Asshole and bullying everybody into such a blatantly illegal pact.

So this is a very real "wage theft" collusion case. Unfortunately most of the parties involved had the "good" sense to NOT document it officially so the Smoking Gun might be hard to prove conclusively.

There was even a "no hire" list at one of these companies tacked on the wall of a HR Manager with the Caption "If you hire from there, we will fire (u) from here."

Re: Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley

#10
post #5

What can the villains in this drama use as power to force their illegal price fixing on reluctant companies? Just what you'd expect. "Mr. Jobs proposed a no-poaching deal to Edward T. Colligan, Palm’s chief executive. Mr. Colligan responded that such a deal would be unfair to employees as well as “likely illegal.” Mr. Jobs then threatened to unleash Apple’s patent lawyers on Palm." Yep. It's our badly broken patent s…

Interesting, since most of Palm's ideas on smartphones pre-dated the iPhone. No wonder we've changed the patent law to first to file, rather than first to invent.
Post reply on HN