Live data from Hacker News

Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

arcticstartup.com

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#5
post #2

Nice, though I wonder what is so notable with the ground track offset.

It shows that the active guidance works as expected. Active guidance is extremely difficult. The hardware is difficult because you need to design jetvanes that work under extreme pressure, and in a 3000 degree jet exhaust. The software is difficult because it needs to be extremely reliable while still compensating for a lot of factors such as wind, spin, air density, etc. and you can't test it, so there is no space for bugs.

No amateurs have ever even attempted active guidance before, and getting it right in the first go is a huge accomplishment.

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#6
post #4

Would that make Denmark the fourth nation to independently achieve manned space flight, behind Russia/USSR, USA and China? Or is it disqualified for not being government run?

It was unmanned. Their final goal is to launch a human into space.

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#7
What this means is that the major obstacles for going into space have been cleared (reliable engine, logistics around sea launch, active guidance) so the next launch will be Heat2x, which has the potential to reach an altitude of 130 km. Space starts at 100 km.

Disclaimer: I'm involved with Copenhagen Suborbitals, and managed the livestreaming of the event.

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#8
post #6
post #4

Would that make Denmark the fourth nation to independently achieve manned space flight, behind Russia/USSR, USA and China? Or is it disqualified for not being government run?

It was unmanned. Their final goal is to launch a human into space.

Hence why I wrote 'would' and not 'does'. My question is if it counts once they actually manage.

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#9
post #5
post #2

Nice, though I wonder what is so notable with the ground track offset.

It shows that the active guidance works as expected. Active guidance is extremely difficult. The hardware is difficult because you need to design jetvanes that work under extreme pressure, and in a 3000 degree jet exhaust. The software is difficult because it needs to be extremely reliable while still compensating for a lot of factors such as wind, spin, air density, etc. and you can't test it, so there is no space f…

Regarding testing, aren't there any possibilities of testing just parts of the software, possibly via simulation, or is everything so inter-dependent that a live physical test is the only way to go? It's pretty impressive to get something so complex right in the first try! Props!

Re: Copenhagen Suborbitals Successfully Launches Active Guided Rocket

#10
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It shows that the active guidance works as expected. Active guidance is extremely difficult. The hardware is difficult because you need to design jetvanes that work under extreme pressure, and in a 3000 degree jet exhaust. The software is difficult because it needs to be extremely reliable while still compensating for a lot of factors such as wind, spin, air density, etc. and you can't test it, so there is no space f…

Regarding testing, aren't there any possibilities of testing just parts of the software, possibly via simulation, or is everything so inter-dependent that a live physical test is the only way to go? It's pretty impressive to get something so complex right in the first try! Props!

You can of course test subsystems, how they play with each other, I/O, etc. But the main job of actually sending the rocket straight up is not testable. You could build simulations, but they wouldn't help much since there are so many parameters, unknowns, etc. that building an accurate simulation would probably be as expensive as a test.

Besides, tests are much more fun!

Post reply on HN