Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–7 of 7 posts

Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

#1

Post by user48 »

hey, recently I've had to start picking up PHP for university. As we do IT-security as a different subject I coded the first assignment for that class in PHP, to get to know PHP better and to try to fix the problem before I implement it in C++.

Now, I am not sure if this code and algorithm are as good as it could be (I am actually pretty sure it isn't) and I want to improve and learn. Hence I was wondering if there is a good place where people give advice on such.

Searching google I didn't seem to find anything matching with the terms I searched for and the forums I found usually had small snippets that were designed for other people to use.

Thanks in advance.

Re: Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

#2

Post by olefoo »

Post a link to your github repository in the appropriate programming subreddit for your language. Make sure that your posting declares that your code solves problem X better than anyone else. Sign off with "and I defy you to find better code in $language anywhere!".

This will result in dozens of helpful strangers posting detailed critiques of your coding style, logic, work flow and parentage. Ignore the invective and look for the ones that post code snippets; if a post with a code snippet says you're doing it wrong, figure out if that is truly a better way of doing things; if so, adopt it.

Re: Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

#3

Post by user48 »

olefoo wrote: post #2

Post a link to your github repository in the appropriate programming subreddit for your language. Make sure that your posting declares that your code solves problem X better than anyone else. Sign off with "and I defy you to find better code in $language anywhere!". This will result in dozens of helpful strangers posting detailed critiques of your coding style, logic, work flow and parentage. Ignore the invective and…

well, that's quite the idea lol.

I will try that, thanks.

Re: Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

#5

Post by jcr »

olefoo wrote: post #2

Post a link to your github repository in the appropriate programming subreddit for your language. Make sure that your posting declares that your code solves problem X better than anyone else. Sign off with "and I defy you to find better code in $language anywhere!". This will result in dozens of helpful strangers posting detailed critiques of your coding style, logic, work flow and parentage. Ignore the invective and…

That's hilarious! And worse, far too true.

Another option would be the codereview part of stackexchange.

http://codereview.stackexchange.com/

Re: Ask HN: Place to get code checked and get advice on it?

#7

Post by user48 »

jcr wrote: post #5
olefoo wrote: post #2

Post a link to your github repository in the appropriate programming subreddit for your language. Make sure that your posting declares that your code solves problem X better than anyone else. Sign off with "and I defy you to find better code in $language anywhere!". This will result in dozens of helpful strangers posting detailed critiques of your coding style, logic, work flow and parentage. Ignore the invective and…

That's hilarious! And worse, far too true. Another option would be the codereview part of stackexchange. http://codereview.stackexchange.com/

that seems just like the kind of place I was looking for, thank you
Post reply on HN