Live data from Hacker News

Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

bits.blogs.nytimes.com

1–10 of 25 posts

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#3
Are people getting so many 2-word "thank you" emails a day to show this article has a valid point? Don't get me wrong, sending merely "thank you" as a reply-all to a 200-person recipient list is one of the biggest email sins. But as a unicast, it serves the purpose of acknowledging receipt. If it was worth sending, it was worth knowing it was received, understood, and appreciated.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#4
My mother realized this long ago. Now we communicate mostly through Twitter.

My first impression was that this is just sad but I guess that different people (and cultures) have different expectations when it comes to communication.

With that said, the author is living inside a bubble created by his environment and his expectations. Saying that everyone should conform to his way of communicating is rude. Saying "thank you" to someone (through whatever communication channel you find most appropriate) is generally not rude.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#5
Maybe this is why the people I interview almost never send us thank you notes. Here I thought it was just a general decline in etiquette, but they're really just being respectful of our time!

Seriously though, I'm curious how many people send thank you emails (or even cards) after an interview. I was always taught that it was extremely rude not to do this, but I'd say as a conservative estimate, we get thank you e-mails after less than 1 of every 10 interviews.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#6
Apologies, but I'm shocked by the self-centered, entitled crap I see here; most if not all of those annecdotes speak to the self-important, self-absorbed nature of modern society.

(Side note: this isn't just my opinion - there's a decent amount of research on the growth of narcissism in modern scotiety. Look at the work of Dr. Jean Twenge, for example)

A small example:

>My father learned this lesson last year after leaving me a dozen voice mail messages, none of which I listened to.

If you enable voicemail and allow people to leave you messages, it's on you to listen to them. Social interactions are no different than product or software design - don't include an affordance for a feature that you don't want the user to use or, worse, will result in guaranteed failure to accomplish the desired task. The fault isn't the caller's.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#8
post #3

Are people getting so many 2-word "thank you" emails a day to show this article has a valid point? Don't get me wrong, sending merely "thank you" as a reply-all to a 200-person recipient list is one of the biggest email sins. But as a unicast, it serves the purpose of acknowledging receipt. If it was worth sending, it was worth knowing it was received, understood, and appreciated.

I think you're missing the point. Sending a thank-you note to a 200-person list is a waste of time and rude to those who don't send such notes at every occasion. If you need acknowledgement than what's better than knowing that other person has read your email? (the default behavior of Facebook messages by the way). It is however another matter if the person who read your email decide to not reply back.

I think this article makes a lot of sense.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#9
I can't tell if this article is supposed to be sarcastic or tongue-in-cheek. I actually think it's part of a worrying pattern from nytimes to be idiotically controversial, perhaps to increase readership and link shares.

Anyway, I'll assume it's serious. A great piece of advice I heard a long time ago: if you constantly feel you're in a rush or don't have enough time for small tasks, you're probably not actually busy, you're mentally disorganized. Simplify the way you perceive the world and properly prioritize things. I feel like that advice applies well to this article. A superfluous e-mail is not a big deal.

Re: Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.

#10
post #5

Maybe this is why the people I interview almost never send us thank you notes. Here I thought it was just a general decline in etiquette, but they're really just being respectful of our time! Seriously though, I'm curious how many people send thank you emails (or even cards) after an interview. I was always taught that it was extremely rude not to do this, but I'd say as a conservative estimate, we get thank you e-ma…

I thought it was standard practice to send thank you emails or cards after an interview. I figured some people forgot, etc, but 1 out of 10 is a lot lower then I expected.

Honestly, it only takes a few minutes to write a simple thank you note and send it, so there's no excuse not to.

Post reply on HN