Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 55 posts

Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#1
Simple question, are you pro zombie movies or against?

(this is a serious question)

The reason why I ask is I'm putting together a digital animation studio as my startup and I'm currently brainstorming ideas for a first show that can be produced with a minimal investment in human capital, using primarily a lot of open source software (which has advanced to the point where this kind of thing is possible)

I originally was discussing this concept here

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=502705

Also, for the sake of intelligent discussion I've got a couple questions.

* Why do you like/hate this film genre, is there anything specific about it that you like/hate?

* What is your favourite Zombie films (for those pro-zombie)?

* For those pro-zombie, is there a specific style you like, eg Romero's horror, Zombie Comedy (Shaun of the dead)

* Is there anything else you'd like to add?

Thanks guys!

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#4
post #3
post #2

Resident Evil FTW!

I'm guessing you're talking about the Milla Jovovich ones and not Resident Evil Degeneration right?

Yeah. Do I get disqualified if I like the movies because of her, though? :-)

(Not sure why I got downvoted, but I did answer a legit question!)

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#5
I'll be honest - Shaun of the Dead is the only one I've seen. I've always felt weird about zombie movies, because like Westerns, without having seen any they all feel very samey. So I wouldn't know where to start watching.

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#6
I voted no, because I don't really like zombie movies on balance. But I am a lover of film and cinema in general.

My beef with zombie movies is that they're usually cliche, and are going for "cheap scares" first and foremost. Often they're punctuated by gore for the sake of gore, and it's done tastelessly. Frequently there's a large cast that you feel no real attachment to and don't bond with, because they need lots of people to kill in a variety of ways.

But the upside: Apocalyptic scenarios in general give lots of options for plot and character development and interaction. I'd say take a look at something like Mad Max - it's a bit campy at times, but I remember some very interesting scenes. There was a relatively small cast that you developed some attachment to, and the sometimes slow pacing made the heavy action scenes really stand out.

Off the top of my head, I can't think of a zombie movie with really exceptional acting and minimal cliches. (If someone who is a fan of this genre can recommend one, I'll check it out). What I'd want out of a zombie movie is focus on character development of just a few people who interact with a broken world. And the filmmaker resisting the temptation to have the "dumb, defiant, big-boobed blond girl who doesn't listen to the leader and thus gets impaled on a fence and eaten" - the zombie scenario itself isn't unsuitable for a good movie, but the execution in these films leaves a lot to be desired.

For inspiration into some unique elements, you might check out the first two Fallout games. It's been a few years and I've not checked out the third, but the first two had some interesting scenarios and plots. In particular, humans interacting with other humans during the apocalypse/zombies could lead to interesting dilemmas and development. In Fallout, the world had fallen apart, and yet there were still people being really petty and villainous instead of uniting. This jives with my understanding of human nature, and makes the games more interesting. Human/human conflicts amidst a zombie background could be a fascinating way to break from the cliches.

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#7
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm guessing you're talking about the Milla Jovovich ones and not Resident Evil Degeneration right?

Yeah. Do I get disqualified if I like the movies because of her, though? :-) (Not sure why I got downvoted, but I did answer a legit question!)

Not at all, I'm trying to discern what the specifics things people like most about zombie films. If it's because of a sexy female lead, then that's a valid point.

What was your opinion on the movements of the zombies? Do you prefer shambling zombies over say the faster movements of some of the other characters?

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#8
post #5

I'll be honest - Shaun of the Dead is the only one I've seen. I've always felt weird about zombie movies, because like Westerns, without having seen any they all feel very samey. So I wouldn't know where to start watching.

I have been told by aficionados that shaun of the dead's zombies are pretty good, authentic even.

In modern times there is a biozombie trend, when they aren't really "undead" so much as a sick human (eg I am Legend, 28 days later etc). I am not sure if it co-incides, but these biozombies seem to have enhanced reflexes, strength and hearing and speed etc... (whereas the old school ones were slow, sad things).

Re: Poll: Do you like zombie movies?

#10

I voted no, because I don't really like zombie movies on balance. But I am a lover of film and cinema in general. My beef with zombie movies is that they're usually cliche, and are going for "cheap scares" first and foremost. Often they're punctuated by gore for the sake of gore, and it's done tastelessly. Frequently there's a large cast that you feel no real attachment to and don't bond with, because they need lots…

But the upside: Apocalyptic scenarios in general give lots of options for plot and character development and interaction.

That's kinda what I was aiming at, plus on the upside, one can generate lots of zombie models randomly fairly quickly and use scripts to animate their shambling.

What I'd want out of a zombie movie is some focus on some character development and the filmmaker resisting the temptation to have the "dumb, defiant, big-boobed blond girl who doesn't listen to the leader and thus gets impaled on a fence and eaten"

Well one of the things I'm looking at is producing episodic web content, so character development (and subsequent demise) is on the agenda. I'm pulling a lot of influence from the Band of Brother's series in that respect.

My beef with zombie movies is that they're usually cliche, and are going for "cheap scares" first and foremost. Often they're punctuated by gore for the sake of gore,

Yeah, I'm trying to judge what people's expectations on blood are.

Thanks for your comments mate, really appreciated.

Post reply on HN