Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

anmlfoundation.org

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–7 of 7 posts

Re: Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

#3

Post by eqvinox »

It's in the format of an "IETF Draft" and has been uploaded on the IETF datatracker web form as an individual submission. It doesn't even name a working group it's targeting for adoption.

It's not an IETF draft. Those are named draft-ietf-*.

You're lying by omission ("individual submission"). Stop.

Re: Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

#4

Post by [deleted] »

eqvinox wrote: post #3

It's in the format of an "IETF Draft" and has been uploaded on the IETF datatracker web form as an individual submission. It doesn't even name a working group it's targeting for adoption. It's not an IETF draft. Those are named draft-ietf-*. You're lying by omission ("individual submission"). Stop.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

#5

Post by ajeskey »

eqvinox wrote: post #3

It's in the format of an "IETF Draft" and has been uploaded on the IETF datatracker web form as an individual submission. It doesn't even name a working group it's targeting for adoption. It's not an IETF draft. Those are named draft-ietf-*. You're lying by omission ("individual submission"). Stop.

I think lying by omission is a bit, of a stretch, how about "hey you may want to submit as a group."

Thanks for your "constructive" feedback, have a great day!

Re: Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

#6

Post by ajeskey »

eqvinox wrote: post #3

It's in the format of an "IETF Draft" and has been uploaded on the IETF datatracker web form as an individual submission. It doesn't even name a working group it's targeting for adoption. It's not an IETF draft. Those are named draft-ietf-*. You're lying by omission ("individual submission"). Stop.

Updated, thanks again.

Re: Show HN: ANML – A machine-first markup language for the agentic web (IETF Draft)

#7

Post by eqvinox »

ajeskey wrote: post #5
eqvinox wrote: post #3

It's in the format of an "IETF Draft" and has been uploaded on the IETF datatracker web form as an individual submission. It doesn't even name a working group it's targeting for adoption. It's not an IETF draft. Those are named draft-ietf-*. You're lying by omission ("individual submission"). Stop.

I think lying by omission is a bit, of a stretch, how about "hey you may want to submit as a group." Thanks for your "constructive" feedback, have a great day!

You can't "submit as a group".

You can request working group adoption, at which point the WG will review your document and form a consensus.

> I think lying by omission is a bit, of a stretch,

No it's not, since you're marketing this as "IETF draft" on HN.

Post reply on HN