Live data from Hacker News

Ban the sale of precise geolocation

lawfaremedia.org

1–10 of 205 posts

Re: Ban the sale of precise geolocation

#3
IMO we should ban gathering this data without a warrant or specific contractual agreement between the device owner and entity aggregating the data. As much as congress loves to claim the interstate commerce theory of everything, this seems like a slam dunk.

Re: Ban the sale of precise geolocation

#7
post #4
post #2

Don't you want random companies to store your precise location for 12 years? https://x.com/dmitriid/status/1817122117093056541

Screenshot in that tweet says 13 months FYI

  > Lifespan: 13 Months
  > ...
  > Standard retention (4320 Days)
It looks like a cookie prompt, so I assume "Lifespan" refers to cookie expiration and "retention" to how long the data (including geolocation) is retained on the spyware company's servers.

Re: Ban the sale of precise geolocation

#8
post #3

IMO we should ban gathering this data without a warrant or specific contractual agreement between the device owner and entity aggregating the data. As much as congress loves to claim the interstate commerce theory of everything, this seems like a slam dunk.

Contractual agreement? Nobody reads things like EULAs or terms of service. It's probably in there already.

Re: Ban the sale of precise geolocation

#9
A lot of geolocation data on the market is anonymized, following medium-lived unique IDs that aren't able to be mapped to other identifiers. The problem with that is that if you have precise locations, or enough samples that you can apply statistics to find precise locations, in many cases you can de-anonymize the IDs. You can purchase address and resident listings from a number of different data vendors, and by checking where the device returns to at night you can figure its home address. Then if you find information on the residents (work locations, schools, etc.), you see if said device goes where each resident of the home address is likely to go, and you now have a pretty good idea of exactly who the device belongs to.

Re: Ban the sale of precise geolocation

#10
post #4
post #2

Don't you want random companies to store your precise location for 12 years? https://x.com/dmitriid/status/1817122117093056541

Screenshot in that tweet says 13 months FYI

[Cookie] Lifespan: 13 Months

Data Retention: Standard Retention (4320 days)

Post reply on HN