Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
1–10 of 127 posts
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#2Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#3if you dont colo your own servers you don't own anything.
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#4if you dont colo your own servers you don't own anything.
I'm confused, what does ownership have to do with this particular failure mode? The issue here is a (for many) unforeseen new tradeoff involved in centralization. Colocating at a central place has the exact same tradeoff in this case: bandwidth is vastly more available and cheaper towards the core, and there are significant amortization gains to be had with a lot of basic shared infra. But it's also one big structure holding a lot of computers and infra everyone is depending on, that's the whole point of it! We're all sharing network backbone and power filtering/redundancy and so on and so forth, vs paying for that separately. That means a missile or drone or bomb hit to the building still hits all of us whether we own the servers there or we're running workloads on someone else's servers.
The only responses are either central counter measures or decentralization. Both have significant costs and complexity, that's why it wasn't just done proactively right?
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#5if you dont colo your own servers you don't own anything.
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#6Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#7I guess it makes me think about what a soft underbelly this could be for a lot of modern society. There's always been consideration of threats to refineries and power stations and industrial production and all those big metal deals. But like, forget any sort of nuclear exchange, any sort of crazy super Starfish style big EMP, just purely a few thousand drones nailing data centers. Nobody even directly dies, just a lot of wrecked computers. What would be the cost of losing all the clouds and colo stuff? How long to replace, at what cost? How much depends on it?
----
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#8if you dont colo your own servers you don't own anything.
> if you dont colo your own servers you don't own anything. I'm confused, what does ownership have to do with this particular failure mode? The issue here is a (for many) unforeseen new tradeoff involved in centralization. Colocating at a central place has the exact same tradeoff in this case: bandwidth is vastly more available and cheaper towards the core, and there are significant amortization gains to be had with…
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#9This may have been long discussed, but I feel like this war is the first time I've really thought hard about how big a target data centers would be in any sort of modern peer war and how that's an entirely new thing since the last time it was really on the radar (end of CW) right? We've built trillions and trillions of dollars in infrastructure in the peace time since, and it seems fairly concentrated. AWS is amongst…
Re: Iran strikes leave Amazon availability zones "hard down" in Bahrain and Dubai
#10This may have been long discussed, but I feel like this war is the first time I've really thought hard about how big a target data centers would be in any sort of modern peer war and how that's an entirely new thing since the last time it was really on the radar (end of CW) right? We've built trillions and trillions of dollars in infrastructure in the peace time since, and it seems fairly concentrated. AWS is amongst…
Given the rapid and increasing rise of AI use in actually fighting wars, I suspect data centers won't just be a big target, they will eventually be the #1 priority target. Taking them offline won't just be of interest in terms of economic damage, it will be a direct strategic goal toward militarily winning the conflict.