Live data from Hacker News

Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

newrepublic.com

1–10 of 45 posts

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#2
the original title is: Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever

which totally fits, did HN's title algorithm cut that off? If so it seems silly. "Than ever" is an important modifier, otherwise someone is apt to think that the subject is more important than some other opposing subject, in this case that Nonfiction publishing is more important than fiction publishing. Anyway I think the "than ever" should be added back in

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#3

the original title is: Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever which totally fits, did HN's title algorithm cut that off? If so it seems silly. "Than ever" is an important modifier, otherwise someone is apt to think that the subject is more important than some other opposing subject, in this case that Nonfiction publishing is more important than fiction publishing. Anyway I think the "than ev…

It's not a title algorithm, it's a character limit.

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#4

the original title is: Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever which totally fits, did HN's title algorithm cut that off? If so it seems silly. "Than ever" is an important modifier, otherwise someone is apt to think that the subject is more important than some other opposing subject, in this case that Nonfiction publishing is more important than fiction publishing. Anyway I think the "than ev…

It's not a title algorithm, it's a character limit.

There isn't a technical reason why titles have to be that short, memory isn't in that short supply despite the RAM shortages. A function, therefore an algorithm, is deciding to truncate the title for some reason.

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#5

the original title is: Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever which totally fits, did HN's title algorithm cut that off? If so it seems silly. "Than ever" is an important modifier, otherwise someone is apt to think that the subject is more important than some other opposing subject, in this case that Nonfiction publishing is more important than fiction publishing. Anyway I think the "than ev…

It's not a title algorithm, it's a character limit.

Full title, "...than ever": 64 characters

Another title currently on the front page has 74 characters: "The Many Roots of Our Suffering: Reflections on Robert Trivers (1943–2026)"

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#7
> Nonfiction books are a crucial bulwark against the surging public culture of “alternative facts,” outright lies, and the brazen embrace of ignorance.

Do they believe someone cannot lie because it’s written down in a paperback? Authors lie in books and books do nothing to help someone who “embraces” ignorance

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#8

the original title is: Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever which totally fits, did HN's title algorithm cut that off? If so it seems silly. "Than ever" is an important modifier, otherwise someone is apt to think that the subject is more important than some other opposing subject, in this case that Nonfiction publishing is more important than fiction publishing. Anyway I think the "than ev…

It's not a title algorithm, it's a character limit.

no, as I indicated the full title is within the character limit, to test it I opened up a submit form and it did not say the title was too long.

Re: Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction

#9
post #7

> Nonfiction books are a crucial bulwark against the surging public culture of “alternative facts,” outright lies, and the brazen embrace of ignorance. Do they believe someone cannot lie because it’s written down in a paperback? Authors lie in books and books do nothing to help someone who “embraces” ignorance

This was dead, I vouched for it, I think it's a good point. Form does not determine the truthfulness of content.
Post reply on HN