Live data from Hacker News

Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

blog.janestreet.com

1–10 of 216 posts

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#3
This is pretty cool, I wasn’t aware of these types of challenges. How does one even approach this?

Feels to me like it’s similar to dumping a binary with an image, the format being entirely custom.

And/or trying to decode a language or cipher, trying to recognize patterns.

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#5
post #175

[stub for offtopicness]

All I think when I see this is "this intelligence wasted on finance and ads."

Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc?

Not everything has to be perfectly efficient but it just saddens me to see all these great minds doing what, adversarially harvesting margin from the works of others?

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#6

This is pretty cool, I wasn’t aware of these types of challenges. How does one even approach this? Feels to me like it’s similar to dumping a binary with an image, the format being entirely custom. And/or trying to decode a language or cipher, trying to recognize patterns.

TFA details a solution, it's pretty interesting. Basically the problem was to reverse engineer an absurdly obfuscated and slightly defect MD5 algorithm.

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#7
post #175

[stub for offtopicness]

All I think when I see this is "this intelligence wasted on finance and ads." Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc? Not everything has to be perfectly efficient but it just saddens me to see all these great minds doing what, adversarially harvesting margin from the works of others?

We don't have any reliable and scalable way of doing this allocation, though, so it's a bit like saying that all the resources are wasted being locked up in asteroids.

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#8
post #175

[stub for offtopicness]

All I think when I see this is "this intelligence wasted on finance and ads." Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc? Not everything has to be perfectly efficient but it just saddens me to see all these great minds doing what, adversarially harvesting margin from the works of others?

Silicon valley had the chance - dont be evil, for humanity, not like those Finance Bros.

At this point tech is probably worse than finance, at least in finance they dont pretend to be saving the world no matter what the giant squid says.

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#9
post #175

[stub for offtopicness]

All I think when I see this is "this intelligence wasted on finance and ads." Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc? Not everything has to be perfectly efficient but it just saddens me to see all these great minds doing what, adversarially harvesting margin from the works of others?

Don't we already harvest more food than humans could ever eat, and have a huge pharmaceutical industry? I get what you're saying but these two examples seem counterproductive imho.

Which begs the question: what would actually be a good field to apply human potential towards? I agree that finance, sales and ads are very low on that list.

Re: Can you reverse engineer our neural network?

#10
post #175

[stub for offtopicness]

All I think when I see this is "this intelligence wasted on finance and ads." Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc? Not everything has to be perfectly efficient but it just saddens me to see all these great minds doing what, adversarially harvesting margin from the works of others?

>Can you imagine human potential if it was somehow applied to crop harvesting efficiency, new medicines, etc?

How is finance not exactly that?

Post reply on HN