Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
1–10 of 67 posts
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#2> information about public employees is uniquely available
It really isn't unique. This report is clearly part of an agenda to establish a two-tier surveillance state.
> The report advocates for legislation that would specifically address privacy concerns for all public servants,
Instead of taking the obvious stance that legislation should ensure the privacy of all people equally, they are only interested in protecting government employees. Sadly, this seems to be a global trend taking root in many countries and it brings me great despair for the future.
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#3> information about public employees is uniquely available It really isn't unique. This report is clearly part of an agenda to establish a two-tier surveillance state. > The report advocates for legislation that would specifically address privacy concerns for all public servants, Instead of taking the obvious stance that legislation should ensure the privacy of all people equally, they are only interested in protecti…
Government employees have power and they are flexing the power.
C'est la vie!
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#4What would happen if we just banned data brokers?
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#5What would happen if we just banned data brokers?
A bunch of leeches would come out from the crevices acting like something that has only been around for a few decades is paramount to American democracy and capitalism where any regulations are akin to a struggle session against liberty, freedom, and justice.
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#6I think EVERYONE is worthy of privacy. The ad cartel has millions (billions?) of lobby money in their war chest. Any real reform would be moving a mountain. Funny how it's framed this way; shows just how impossible it is to concede to privacy for all. Instead we have as another commenter said: "a two-tier surveillance state."
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#7> information about public employees is uniquely available It really isn't unique. This report is clearly part of an agenda to establish a two-tier surveillance state. > The report advocates for legislation that would specifically address privacy concerns for all public servants, Instead of taking the obvious stance that legislation should ensure the privacy of all people equally, they are only interested in protecti…
I cannot speak for the US but in Germany there is certainly some amount of violence towards local politicians but also other parts of administration (job centers, etc)
Traditionally there was maximum transparency (names of every single reponsible person for each minor municipal job) with little choice for employees to opt out. This is changing not under special rules but mostly under GDPR adoption. However, particularly elected officials (even for very minor local roles) even have to expose their street address to get elected (such legal requirements can provide GDPR exception). This generates real risk. If less and less or the "wrong" people go into administration we are in trouble, IMHO. I know there is a lot of governments vs the people sentiment popping up. But we need to just make sure that we treat our administration also as people in certain situations. (Disclaimer: as a university lecturer I am officially a public servant, but I do not think any of this would apply to me: I hardly have to fear the wrath of the students)
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#8> information about public employees is uniquely available It really isn't unique. This report is clearly part of an agenda to establish a two-tier surveillance state. > The report advocates for legislation that would specifically address privacy concerns for all public servants, Instead of taking the obvious stance that legislation should ensure the privacy of all people equally, they are only interested in protecti…
I cannot speak for the US but in Germany there is certainly some amount of violence towards local politicians but also other parts of administration (job centers, etc) Traditionally there was maximum transparency (names of every single reponsible person for each minor municipal job) with little choice for employees to opt out. This is changing not under special rules but mostly under GDPR adoption. However, particula…
The report linked in the article doesn't mention existing laws mandating disclosure of public servant details or anything of that nature. It primarily focuses on private data brokers collecting and selling data, a threat model which applies to all people equally. Rather than addressing the problem at its root, which is the data brokers blatantly violating the privacy of everyone, by all appearances they are perfectly fine with what data brokers do as long as they are able to exempt themselves from it.
I think that posting street addresses for "maximum transparency" is a bit silly, and it would probably make sense to repeal legislation that makes government employee's sensitive private information public. That principle should also apply equally to all citizens, though. If I'm not mistaken, I believe anyone who hosts a website in Germany is mandated by law to post their address on the website, which is completely unfathomable to me.
We do also see the two-tier surveillance hierarchy attempting to be established across the EU, in general. Chat Control in all its forms is always proposed with an exemption for government employees.
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#9What would happen if we just banned data brokers?
A bunch of leeches would come out from the crevices acting like something that has only been around for a few decades is paramount to American democracy and capitalism where any regulations are akin to a struggle session against liberty, freedom, and justice.
See also: DHS/TSA/ICE, credit scores, stock buybacks and self-dividends.
All very, very recent systems in the grander scheme.
Re: Data Brokers Can Fuel Violence Against Public Servants
#10Anyone who says anything, anywhere, gets threats. Is there any data showing the follow-through percent is any higher for public servants?