Live data from Hacker News

Why we don’t use AI

yarnspinner.dev

1–10 of 86 posts

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#2
I wish. I have just witnessed a engineer on our (small) team push a 4k line change to prod at the middle of the night. His message was: "lets merge and check it after". AI can help good team become better, but for sure it will make bad teams worse.

I sorry friends, I think imma quit to farming :$

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#3

I wish. I have just witnessed a engineer on our (small) team push a 4k line change to prod at the middle of the night. His message was: "lets merge and check it after". AI can help good team become better, but for sure it will make bad teams worse. I sorry friends, I think imma quit to farming :$

One should not be able to push to prod on their own especially in the middle of the night? Unless its a critical fix

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#5

I wish. I have just witnessed a engineer on our (small) team push a 4k line change to prod at the middle of the night. His message was: "lets merge and check it after". AI can help good team become better, but for sure it will make bad teams worse. I sorry friends, I think imma quit to farming :$

One should not be able to push to prod on their own especially in the middle of the night? Unless its a critical fix

Who cares, AI has lowered the bar. If AI can produce rubbish 20+% of the time, so can we.

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#6

I wish. I have just witnessed a engineer on our (small) team push a 4k line change to prod at the middle of the night. His message was: "lets merge and check it after". AI can help good team become better, but for sure it will make bad teams worse. I sorry friends, I think imma quit to farming :$

Try to comply to an infosec standard. Typically one of many compliance controls are "every change must be reviewed and approved by another person". So no one can push on their own.

I know folks tend to frown on security compliances, but if you honestly implement and maintain most of the controls in there, not just to get a certificate -- it really make a lot of sense and improves security/clarity/risks.

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#9

I wish. I have just witnessed a engineer on our (small) team push a 4k line change to prod at the middle of the night. His message was: "lets merge and check it after". AI can help good team become better, but for sure it will make bad teams worse. I sorry friends, I think imma quit to farming :$

One should not be able to push to prod on their own especially in the middle of the night? Unless its a critical fix

> Unless its a critical fix

The bar for human approval and testing should be even higher for critical fixes.

Re: Why we don’t use AI

#10
One could probably think of dozens of reasonable arguments for avoiding LLM use, but this one is awful. If LLMs actually are able to get more work done with fewer people aka "firing people" that would be wonderful for humankind. If you disagree and like getting less work done with more people, you are welcome to forego tractors, dishwashers, the steam engine, and all the rest.
Post reply on HN